- Agent Pronto
- New York
- Shelter Island
Find the perfect real estate agent in Shelter Island, NY
We analyze top real estate agents in Shelter Island and across the country to find you the most proven local agents, for free.
Compare the top real estate agents in Shelter Island
Agent Pronto analyzes transaction data, specialties, client reviews, and more to find the best agent for you. Updated for June 2025. *
* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.
The easiest way to find the best real estate agent.
Sell your home fast and for top dollar or find your dream home at the best possible price. Use our free service to find top agents you can trust.
- Tell us what you need.
- Answer a few quick questions about your real estate needs so we can begin our search.
- Match with the perfect agent.
- Our personalized matching system will connect you with a top-rated real estate agent with the local expertise and experience you need.
- Meet your agent.
- Review the details of your top agent recommendations and speak with them to learn exactly how they can make your real estate journey a success.
- Buy and sell with confidence.
- While real estate decisions are among the most important financial and personal decisions we make, you can rest easy knowing that you have a proven real estate professional on your side.
Home buyers and sellers love Agent Pronto.
Here’s what some of the 400,000+ home buyers and sellers have had to say about our service.
“Michelle is an excellent agent. Her understanding of the market and the available options for sale was outstanding. I would highly recommend Michelle as an agent.”
“Agent Pronto's recommendation of Lenny Sklyar was excellent. I was able to sell my house, which I thought would be difficult to do.”
“Colette is responsive, efficient and an absolute pleasure to work with. Robert (my fiancé) and I were first time co-op buyers and Colette walked us through the process seamlessly. Thank you for connecting us with Colette. We appreciate it.”
“I was selling my mom's house and didn't live in the area. I picked the right agent, Alice Regan. She was fabulous!! Very easy to talk to. Explaining everything!! Returned all calls and emails. She is a very busy agent BUT made me feel like it was just me she was working for. Highly recommend her!”
“Very fast, excellent customer service! Connected me with a really great realtor who was constantly communicating with us regarding every step in the process of selling our house. Very impressed with the service and would highly recommend.”
“Kay Moon was an outstanding agent who provided top tier service in the listing and sale of my apartment. I highly recommend her to anyone who is selling or buying property.”
“Harold Baldwin was a great assist to me for purchasing my new home. He was able to help me get assistance to help with the purchase of the home. Harold is the best - very knowledgeable, kind, understanding and looked for homes exactly what is asked of. Couldn't ask for a better Realtor! Thank you so much. ”
“I wasn't having luck with realtors at the time, so I decided to give AgentPronto.com a try. They ended up matching me with an amazing agent, that I so happened to have went to high school with. It was a great experience and without Agent Pronto, I wouldn't have found Jason Maddison & Alex Colin, and I would not be in my dream home!”
“Joanne was a pleasure to work with. We will continue with the sale of my apartment too, and we even became friends! ”
“Hermi was polite, responsive, knowledgable, kind, respectful, and he sold the property quickly. He discussed all concerns with me openly and remained in frequent contact.”
Shelter Island real estate Market Report.
Information and statistics on the latest trends in the Shelter Island real estate market, updated for June 2025. *
Shelter Island had 8 new listings and 1 listings that went under contract in April, decreasing the area’s total available inventory to 20—down 4.76% from the previous month. Inventory is projected to have further decreased in May.
Of those 20 active listings, 20.0% reduced their price in the month of April. The median listing price for homes in Shelter Island fell 64.47% from March to April, bringing the current median listing price to $2,247,000. Based on projected data for May, listing prices may continue to fall.
Market gauge is calculated based on the the number of active listings divided by home sales over the most recently available reporting period.
Learn more about what Shelter Island has to offer.
Shelter Island offers its residents a charming blend of scenic beauty, tranquil outdoor activities, and a tight-knit community atmosphere.
Shelter Island offers a truly distinctive lifestyle, blending tranquil coastal beauty with a vibrant sense of community. Surrounded by Suffolk County and accessible by ferry, this island feels almost worlds away while still being conveniently close to East End destinations like Greenport and the Hamptons. Here, winding lanes lead to pristine beaches like Wades Beach, where crystalline waters invite swimming, paddling, and sunset strolls. Nature lovers revel in the vast ecological preserves at Mashomack Preserve, a sanctuary for osprey, otters, and quiet woodland adventures.
For families considering a move, education is a cornerstone, with Shelter Island School offering an intimate, K-12 learning environment renowned for individualized attention and strong community support. The local library, Shelter Island Public Library, serves as a cultural hub, hosting enriching programs, book clubs, and community events year-round. Local cuisine and fresh seafood shine at beloved spots like Salt Waterfront Bar & Grill, while community traditions—like the annual Shelter Island 10K, draw neighbors and visitors together to celebrate the island’s spirit.
With quiet lanes ideal for cycling and a calendar dotted with farmers’ markets and art fairs, Shelter Island delivers a pace of life that is both relaxed and engaging. Whether you envision lazy summer days by the water or year-round small-town camaraderie, this destination feels both exclusive and warmly welcoming. For those ready to buy or sell a home on Shelter Island, Agent Pronto stands ready to make your transition seamless and rewarding.
Within a few minutes, I was paired up with an awesome agent who really knew the local area and helped me find a great condo in a super tight market. It was daunting to think about how to find the right agent. Agent Pronto got me the right agent, pronto!
Take the guesswork out of finding an agent.
With over 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., it’s not easy deciding who to trust when buying or selling a home.
We’ve analyzed performance metrics, close rates, specialties, and client reviews of the top real estate agents in Shelter Island to qualify the best agents for your specific needs.
We know that choosing the right real estate agent can be a stressful task. With Agent Pronto, it doesn’t have to be.
Data analysis with a human touch.
Agent Pronto works through troves of local and national housing data, client reviews, and agent performance metrics to find the top agents in Shelter Island. But we don’t stop there.
Our Agent Specialists will take into account any special requests you have when searching for your real estate agent recommendation.
Need a great agent who speaks fluent Spanish and is a luxury condo expert in your neighborhood? No problem!
Resources for buyers and sellers.
Tips and market insights to make your Shelter Island real estate journey a success.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
There are more than 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., and you want to be sure the one you partner with is an experienced and trustworthy professional with strong local expertise. Working with a proven agent will help you sell your home faster and for more money, and help you find your dream home at the best possible price.
-
Choosing a real estate agent to help you buy or sell property is one of the most important decisions you’ll make in your lifetime. You want to make sure your agent is an expert in your area, has a proven record helping people buy and sell similar homes to yours, and is well regarded by their previous clients. Let us know a few details about the property you are selling or the kind of home you want to buy, and Agent Pronto will match you with trusted real estate agents that have the experience you need. And before you interview an agent, check out our top five questions to ask a buyer’s agent and listing agent.
-
We consider performance metrics, close rates, specialties, and client reviews to qualify the best full-time agents. We then take the information you provide about the home you are selling or the kind of home you want to buy, and analyze the top local agents with the right experience for your specific needs. For more than a decade, we've helped hundreds of thousands of home buyers and sellers find the right agent. Get started now and find the perfect real estate agent.
-
No. Agent Pronto is a free service for home buyers and sellers and you are under no obligation to work with our recommended agents.
Looking for an agent in a nearby city?
We can help you find the perfect real estate agent just about anywhere.