Teddy Cafaro

Compass

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
Teddy Cafaro approaches New York City real estate with a steady hand, a collaborative mindset, and a deep understanding of the city's complex residential market. A native New Yorker and licensed real estate salesperson with Compass, Teddy has spent more than a decade helping buyers and sellers navigate transactions throughout Manhattan and Brooklyn.

With particular expertise in co-op and condominium resales, Teddy works with everyone from first-time homebuyers to seasoned purchasers, sellers, and clients relocating to New York City. His experience spans property valuation, pricing strategy, negotiations, co-op board approvals, and the many intricacies of buying and selling in one of the country's most competitive real estate markets.

Before entering real estate, Teddy worked as a professional musician, an experience that shaped his approach to communication, preparation, and collaboration. He understands that successful transactions require buyers, sellers, attorneys, lenders, and brokers to work together toward a common goal.

Teddy prides himself on being responsive, thoughtful, and genuinely invested in his clients' success. His philosophy is straightforward: provide sound advice, communicate clearly, and deliver enough value that clients return to him and confidently recommend him to others.

In addition to Manhattan and Brooklyn, Teddy works with clients exploring properties in the Hudson Valley and Catskills.
Highlights *
9
Recent sales
$358K - $2.08M
Price range
$715K
Median price
8
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
33 E End Ave #4F
New York, NY 10028
7/20/2026 $775,000 Buyer
75 Henry St #23D
Brooklyn, NY 11201
6/5/2026 $650,000 Buyer
293 Riverside Dr #2B
New York, NY 10025
1/6/2026 $357,500 Seller
11 W 69th St #1D
New York, NY 10023
9/19/2025 $715,000 Buyer
202 Seeley St #2E
Brooklyn, NY 11218
9/15/2025 $999,000 Buyer

Transaction History *

Seller Deals

Total Deals
2
Total Value
$797,000
Median Sale Price
$398,500
Price Range
$358K - $440K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
7
Total Value
$6,699,000
Median Sale Price
$775,000
Price Range
$525K - $2.08M

Sales Volume Timeline

Teddy Cafaro’s production volume for the past 3 year period Q1 ’24 Q1 2024 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2024): $0 Q2 ’24 Q2 2024 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2024): $0 Q3 ’24 Q3 2024 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2024): $960K Q4 ’24 Q4 2024 (Oct 1–Dec 31, 2024): $0 Q1 ’25 Q1 2025 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2025): $525K Q2 ’25 Q2 2025 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2025): $2.1M Q3 ’25 Q3 2025 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2025): $2.2M Q4 ’25 Q4 2025 (Oct 1–Dec 31, 2025): $0 Q1 ’26 Q1 2026 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2026): $358K Q2 ’26 Q2 2026 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2026): $650K Q3 ’26 Q3 2026 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2026): $775K Q1 2024 Total Sales $0 Q2 2024 Total Sales $0 Q3 2024 Total Sales $960K Q4 2024 Total Sales $0 Q1 2025 Total Sales $525K Q2 2025 Total Sales $2.1M Q3 2025 Total Sales $2.2M Q4 2025 Total Sales $0 Q1 2026 Total Sales $358K Q2 2026 Total Sales $650K Q3 2026 Total Sales $775K

Sales volume is shown for complete quarters only.

Professional Info

Brokerage

Compass
851 Madison Avenue 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10021

Licensed

Licensed Real Estate Agent
NY 10401318865

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Luxury properties
  • Relocation

Hobbies

  • Music
  • Outdoor Activities

Education

The Johns Hopkins University
Bachelor’s Degree, Anthropology, Film
2005 - 2009

*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.