1. Agent Pronto
  2. New Jersey
  3. Middletown
  4. Top Real Estate Agents

Top Real Estate Agents In Middletown - Page 3

Agent Pronto analyzes transaction data, agent specialties, and client reviews to handpick the best agents in your area. Updated for August 2026.*

Michelle Lorme
5.0 (3)
Real Broker LLC

49 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$540-$1.44M price range

$531K median price

Francesco Rubino
My Society Real Estate

60 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$238K-$965K price range

$485K median price

Supreme Home Team
Keller Williams West Monmouth

70 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$22K-$1.5M price range

$450K median price

Nicole Slohoda
5.0 (2)
Keller Williams Elite Realtors

21 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$343K-$800K price range

$520K median price

Lucy Palmese
Coldwell Banker Realty

65 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$20K-$1.08M price range

$475K median price

Mary Ann Azzolina
5.0 (3)
Coldwell Banker Eastern Monmouth office

7 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$108K-$869K price range

$320K median price

Joe Colella
Exp realty

69 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$252K-$1.35M price range

$570K median price

Wendy Crispe
RE/MAX Homeland West

51 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$40K-$1.37M price range

$443K median price

Michael Harbord
5.0 (45)
1st First Class Real Estate Agency

95 recent sales

$495-$1.15M price range

$399K median price

Dana Cirlincione
Robert DeFalco Realty

34 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$178K-$1.7M price range

$705K median price

Joyce Fernandes
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, Fox & Roach Realtors

35 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$25K-$1.23M price range

$595K median price

Michelle Vega
EXP Realty

22 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$38K-$945K price range

$527K median price

Kevin Guilford
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage

18 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$330K-$1.28M price range

$560K median price

Susan Lucas Sterling
5.0 (45)
RE/MAX at Barnegat Bay

154 recent sales

$18K-$2.4M price range

$400K median price

Andrew Campbell
Redfin

10 recent sales (1 in Middletown)

$285K-$675K price range

$490K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.