Amy Corey

The Corey Connection at Keller Williams

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
77 recent sales
$49K - $1.15M
20 years experience
About
I consider myself a "Real Estate Brat" having had a mom in the business for 36 years. I have served my community for 12 years in real estate and my husband, Jeff, came into the business with me in 2014. Together we pride ourselves on our attention to detail and communication with our clients.
As a client of the Corey Connection, you should expect a high level of service and communication. We work to build a relationship with our clients and serve our clients to the best of our abilities.
This sense of relationship and service means that we will take the time to educate you on the in's and out's of the buying or selling process, if you are a first time home buyer, or refresh you if it has been a while. We help you navigate the decision-making and negotiation process, and consistently follow up and follow through with the responsibilities with which you trust us.
We look forward to the opportunity to earn your business.

Sincerely,

Amy Corey

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (112)

Jenny Riddell
Zionsville, IN - May 2, 2025

Amy Corey did a super job! If it weren't for help, I wouldn't be in my dream home!

Joe Hines
Noblesville, IN - Apr 22, 2025

We've used Amy before and will continue to use her.

Mary Little
Carmel, IN - Aug 5, 2024

Amy made the process of finding a home such a good experience! She was helpful, knowledgeable and understood exactly what we wanted and needed. She went above and beyond to make sure we found what we desired. Because we were hunting for a home out of state, she covered every detail that we might have missed and made sure we knew the area as best as possible. Our move couldn't have been the same without Amy and we would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a house.

Tiffany
Fishers, IN - Aug 5, 2024

Amy went above and beyond in helping us view homes and purchase a home from out of state. She is very knowledgeable about the area and about neighborhoods we were viewing. She responded to our questions and concerns quickly and helped us secure the perfect home for us. Highly recommend!

David Vawter
Bowling Green, KY - Aug 5, 2024

Amy stepped into a challenging family situation and handled every aspect of selling our parents' longtime home with grace and consummate professionalism. She made a difficult time much less stressful, and the outcome was to everyone's satisfaction.

BW
Westfield, IN - Apr 23, 2024

Amy Corey, did an outstanding job with the purchase of my new home and i would highly recommend her to all my friends!

Mr. & Mrs. McClary
Cumming, GA - Apr 15, 2024

Working with agent, Amy Corey , was made easy by her constant comunication and follow-up on any question we had. We sold very quickly for $5,000.00 over our asking price.

Amy O'Donnell
New Palestine, IN - Oct 28, 2023

Amy was professional, kind, efficient, and effective in assessing our home's value, strategizing and executing a marketing plan.

Amy was kind and helpful, easy to contact and quick to respond.

Julie Shearer
IN - Aug 4, 2023

Randy and I appreciated all the hard work you did to make moving so smooth.

Mike & Brynn
Fishers, IN - Jul 7, 2023

Amy Corey was an incredible help in our homebuying process! She came highly recommended by family, and she exceeded our expectations.

As first time buyers, we had a lot of questions and needed the process broken down for us in terms we could understand. Amy was clear, communicative, and knowledgable. She helped build our confidence in the process and worked hard to build a relationship with us (not an easy feat considering we were buying from out of state!). We talked on the phone, via text, and email, and she was able to get a sense for what was most important for our family in this big life step.

Amy was always open to our thoughts and questions, and we felt heard and understood. She took us on FaceTime tours of so many properties, and she was quick to jump into action when listings popped up in neighborhoods we were excited to see or with properties that sparked our interest.

We are so grateful for her expertise and support -- Amy is the very best!

Mark Brown
IN - Jan 11, 2023

Amy is a wonderful broker. I would say this regardless if she had not sold my house. I remember her sitting down with us and walking us through the entire process. I recall he optimism that we were going to sale the house. I'm was floored by the communication. I believe it was daily we got updates and recommendations. When we sent her an email or a text message she responded immediately displaying her commitment to us. I recall her saying if you need a referral for a vendor or need information let me know. She also said if you need boxes or help packing I'll help. I thought that was just something a broker would say, but the more I learned and worked with her I believe she would've packed for us if we needed her. She is a true professional and dedicated to her trade. I highly recommend her and in the future if have a need to buy or sell I would not hesitate to call her.

Jessica Revell
Fishers, IN - Jan 4, 2023

Amy was absolutely fantastic!! I was recommended to her by my mom and I could not have chosen a better realtor. She was so patient with me with buying my first house and answered all my questions.

Samantha Higdon
Fishers, IN - Dec 9, 2022

Amy was amazing- the perfect person for me to work with.

She was patient, understanding of my needs, recognizing when I was hesitant about a property, and when I was excited about one.

Never once did I feel rushed, like I wasn't a priority, or that Amy wanted anything less than the absolute perfect home for me.

With everything going on in the market and my personal life while trying to decide on a home, I genuinely don't think I could have navigated this whole process without her!

I would without a doubt recommend Amy to anyone looking to purchase or sell a home. If I ever move, Amy's my first call!

Clay Hinrichsen
Avon, IN - Dec 8, 2022

Amy was referred to us by a co-worker and lived up to every expectation. With this being our first home purchase we had a number of questions as well as nerves. Amy was understanding, accessible, and did everything she could to help us win the home we hoped for. In the end I couldn't have asked for a better realtor to work with and will absolutely use her again in the future should the opportunity present itself.

Xander H
Indianapolis, IN - Nov 9, 2022

As a first time home buyer, Amy Corey's knowledge and accessibility were crucial for helping me through each step of the home buying process. All of my questions were answered thoroughly and promptly, and thanks to Amy I found exactly the house I was looking for.

Stephanie B.
Anderson, IN - Oct 11, 2022

Amy was always keeping us up to date on our status and what was next in the process. She even kept us informed when she was moving herself. She's excellent at what she does!

Ally Weipert
Fishers, IN - May 28, 2022

We were referred to her by David sidoni how has a how to buy a home podcast. His information is one we came to trust and wanted to see who he would refer to in our new search area. After speaking with Amy and looking her up we liked the idea of working with her.

Amy was such a wonderful resource for us as first time home buyers in a brand new area. Her insights to the area really helped us, the local environment and house related concerns and costs, and her recommendations were always in line with our vision as well. She showed her care for our family in all the work and consideration she put into finding and securing us a home.

I will recommend her to everyone I know she was the epitome of a local expert. She was friendly, knowledgeable, accessible and clear communicator. She really understood our vision of the home we had in mind.

Amy's experience and balanced approach to this crazy market we're invaluable in our purchase. She always positioned us as best as possible in our negotiations and had such a balanaced approach to taking on risk. Everything she did showed how she saw us as people and friends rather than a transaction to be rushed through for a commission. You can tell that is a natural gift of hers, to care for everyone she crosses paths with and leave the world a little kinder than before.

Dianne McKinley
IN - Apr 4, 2022

My husband and I have worked with Amy Corey twice before and we would never even consider using another agent. Amy is the BEST and we wouldn't trust anyone else with our home purchase.

Amy Corey is the picture of a top notch agent. She is professional, warm, and has a great attention to detail.

Devin Z.
Indianapolis, IN - Jan 4, 2022

Amy is incredible at her job, but is also an incredible friend. She only performs with excellence and professionalism, no matter how intense the situation can be. I would highly recommend her for anyone buying, or selling their home.

Steve A
McCordsville, IN - Dec 30, 2021

Amy was professional from the beginning. She was also very sensitive to the feelings we were going through at the time of the sale. She kept us informed, honored our desires for the sale, and kept the process moving forward. When the documentation, the day before the closing, was incorrect, Amy caught it and had it fixed immediately so as not delay the closing. She was patient, if not directive, with a fairly inexperienced closing agent on their side, but assured all was in order and correctly done.

She is a consummate professional, a super nice person, and I would not only recommend her to others, but I would take issue if my powerful recommendation wasn't accepted! I've worked with Amy 2x now (a purchase and a sale of a house). Always a wonderful experience!

Peg Neal
Fishers, IN - Dec 28, 2021

House sold 1 day after being on market. Every aspect of the sale was done fairly and with ease. Communication were excellent. Amy was just incredible!

I didn’t know such fine service was possible. So reassuring.

Katie Holmes
Indianapolis, IN - Jul 16, 2021

Amy Corey was recommended to me by two close friends who I trust very much, and she was a rock star from start to finish! As a first-time home purchaser, there is a lot to navigate and it can be overwhelming, especially with such a competitive market. I had a lot of questions and Amy was patience, clear and extremely responsive throughout the entire process. She also anticipated so many things I would have never thought about on my own! In a competitive market, her strategic approach and historical knowledge were invaluable, and I truly believe I would not have my amazing house if it weren't for her guidance! Her friendly personality and upbeat attitude were just the icing on the cake! I would recommend Amy Corey to anyone who is in the market to sell or buy - she's incredible!

Lou Epperson
IN - Sep 27, 2020

Smooth transactions. Amy was always available for any question I had.

Jan
Fishers, IN - Mar 27, 2020

Amy again is awesome. She ensures that you understand everything and works with you on anything at any time of the day, evening or weekend to get it done. She sold the house in less than 2 days and I am still very appreciative of her expertise as a realtor. Thanks Amy!

Amanda Zahorsky
Westfield, IN - Mar 6, 2020

Amy was very patient with us when purchasing our "forever home". We were specific in what we needed and she paid close attention to our needs and never lost sight of the goal.

Professional Info

Brokerage

The Corey Connection at Keller Williams
8555 N River Road Suite 200
Indianapolis, IN 46240

Licensed

License Real Estate Agent
IN RB14041612

Top Cities *

Indianapolis

  • 24 sales past 3 years
  • 43 days on market
  • $270K median price

Fishers

  • 14 sales past 3 years
  • 54 days on market
  • $445K median price

Carmel

  • 10 sales past 3 years
  • 30 days on market
  • $600K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.