Peter Vitale

Robert Defalco Realty

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
I’m Peter Vitale, a dedicated real estate agent with over 5 years of experience helping buyers, sellers, and renters navigate the market with confidence. I pride myself on being responsive, honest, and making the process as smooth as possible. Whether you’re looking to find the perfect home or maximize your property’s value, I’m here to guide you every step of the way.
Highlights *
8
Recent sales
$350K - $1.36M
Price range
$655K
Median price
5
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
42 Everton Ave
Staten Island, NY 10312
2/17/2026 $813,000 Seller
295 Rensselaer Ave
Staten Island, NY 10312
12/29/2025 $1,362,000 Buyer
6 Arc Pl #A4
Staten Island, NY 10306
10/16/2025 $485,000 Seller
396 St Marks Pl
Staten Island, NY 10301
6/12/2025 $350,000 Seller
35 Pamela Ln
Staten Island, NY 10304
1/17/2025 $650,000 Seller

Ratings & Reviews
4.7 (12)

zuser20170727075505230
Oct 24, 2023

Was connected with Pete through my mortgage bank. Working with Pete was a great experience. Worked with me and my wife for about a year to find a house, patient and knowledgeable. Responds back quickly. Very down to earth and easy to work with. Not pushy either like some other realtors. Next house I will definitely work with Pete again.

Zillow Verified

Jay kicks
Oct 11, 2023

Peter was very lazy doesn’t answer questions about properties had an attitude every time I asked simple questions like was the place cleaned after past tenants left. I wouldn’t recommend him ( showed up half hour late) to show an apartment doesn’t talk much on his phone

Zillow Verified

Sangh
Oct 28, 2022

It was a pleasure working with Peter Vitale. We had a smooth experience buying a home thanks to him. Throughout the entire process, he was absolutely amazing and extremely quick to respond.

Thank you so much for finding us our dream home, Peter.

Zillow Verified

anthonyfavale6
Jul 25, 2022

Pete was absolutely what you are looking for when selling a house. He was very respectful and supportive the our goals, even when lower but very reasonable offers came to the table. He encouraged us to stick to our desired number even though it may have risked his commission.

Zillow Verified

vkrdzdc8bv
Nov 4, 2021

I’m a very busy healthcare provider who needed someone knowledgeable and professional to help rent my apartment. He checked the applicants and sent that data to review.
Kept working hard on the listing and great communication: provided useful updates and advice. Thank you

Zillow Verified

Professional Info

Brokerage

Robert Defalco Realty
1678 Hylan Boulevard
Staten Island, NY 10305

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
NY 10401323584

*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.