1. Agent Pronto
  2. Ohio
  3. Westerville
  4. Craig & Amy Balster
Team

Craig & Amy Balster

Keller Williams Excel Realty

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
If you’re looking for a Realtor in Columbus, let us be your guide. We've been helping sell and buy homes for over 10 years, and are absolutely ready to help you buy your dream home or sell your current home for top dollar!
Our Facebook page is another way you can connect with us or you can visit ColumbusCraigandAmy.com!
Highlights *
51
Recent sales
$150K - $3.55M
Price range
$383K
Median price
15
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
3722 Florian Dr
Columbus, OH 43219
8/6/2025 $315,000 Buyer
3075 Jersey Dr # 73
Columbus, OH 43204
7/21/2025 $149,900 Seller
6337 Waterwood Dr
Westerville, OH 43082
5/23/2025 $775,000 Seller
4231 Sighthill Ave
Powell, OH 43065
3/11/2025 $401,000 Buyer
2312 Pinzon Pl # 104
Columbus, OH 43235
2/19/2025 $214,000 Seller

Ratings & Reviews
5.0 (88)

Sara Kroboth
Jun 4, 2026

My husband and I recently bought a house and sold our condo with Craig Balster as our realtor and we have nothing but wonderful things to say about our experience working with him! Craig’s calm demeanor and guidance, support and expertise made both processes move forward with ease. Craig was very patient with us throughout the journey and was always available to answer any of our questions and quick to schedule showings for us on all homes we were interested in viewing. If you find yourself in need of a realtor, look no further than Balster Realty Group!

Zillow Verified

Elise Whitesell
Mar 19, 2026

Craig was fantastic to work with. He took the time to get to know us over a year ago and when we decided not to move forward with the home buying process at that time, he stayed in contact with us until we were ready. The process was smooth and easy and we highly recommend him and his team to anyone buying or selling a home!

Zillow Verified

Natalie Taylor
Jan 28, 2026

Craig is fantastic. Our house sold in 1 day. Craig gave us sage advice on pricing and area comps., was prompt for all meetings, communicated clearly, kept us informed on next steps, and even helped welcome us to our new home. We can't recommend Craig enough. He's a true gem!

Zillow Verified

gfisher0
Jan 1, 2025

"Craig and Amy were amazing and made our forever home purchase memorable and special. Their patience and kindness working with us to find a home was incredible. We changed our minds often and they helped us understand the process completely. They worked to find what we wanted in the our price range and were ready to look at homes during our free time. Without them we couldn't have gotten or our forever home that our kids will truly love. Craig and Amy truly became friends not just our realtors."

Zillow Verified

fellers ash
Nov 20, 2024

We had the wonderful experience of having Amy's help in guiding us through several real estate transactions.. purchasing land, building a new house, and selling our home. She was an invaluable member of the team that made the purchase, build and sale a reality!
Her network and processes made our transition a smooth one and her insights in each step of the way helped to take away a lot of our stress and anxiety.
In addition to everything you'd expect, all of her little touches really added up to make a big difference and her connections and recommendations each step of the way really added a lot of value to our process. From finding our lot, to helping negotiate our build, to marketing and selling our home, she really shined!

Zillow Verified

Professional Info

Brokerage

Keller Williams Excel Realty
550 Polaris Pkwy
Westerville, OH 43082

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
OH 2014003850

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Luxury properties
  • Relocation

Top Cities *

Westerville

  • 19 sales past 3 years
  • 32 days on market
  • $460K median price

Columbus

  • 12 sales past 3 years
  • 37 days on market
  • $260K median price

Powell

  • 4 sales past 3 years
  • 56 days on market
  • $401K median price

*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.