Theresa Bartels

The Indy Realty Shop

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
As a seasoned real estate broker with 17 years of experience and a strong support team, I am dedicated to helping you achieve your real estate goals. My focus is on delivering the highest level of service possible, whether you are looking to sell your home for top dollar or find the best possible deal on your next home purchase.

As your broker, I see myself as a general manager working on your behalf. I understand that there are many moving parts involved in any real estate transaction, and my expertise in working with various vendors, inspectors, title companies, and lenders ensures that every detail is taken care of seamlessly, so you don't have to worry about a thing.

One of my top priorities is your bottom line. When I sell a home, I work tirelessly to ensure that my clients get the best possible return on their investment. In every transaction, my focus is on delivering the best outcome for my clients, which includes being a fierce negotiator on their behalf.
Highlights *
47
Recent sales
$148K - $830K
Price range
$310K
Median price
20
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
6617 S Lawndale Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46221
8/28/2026 $260,000 Buyer
1701 Crimson Ln
Lebanon, IN 46052
6/15/2026 $199,000 Buyer
901 N. 9th St
Elwood, IN 46036
5/11/2026 $147,500 Buyer
901 N 9th St
Elwood, IN 46036
5/11/2026 $147,500 Buyer
19226 Potters Bridge Rd
Noblesville, IN 46060
4/2/2026 $320,000 Buyer

Transaction History *

Seller Deals

Total Deals
19
Total Value
$6,691,700
Median Sale Price
$305,000
Price Range
$160K - $830K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
28
Total Value
$9,237,290
Median Sale Price
$314,750
Price Range
$148K - $720K

Sales Volume Timeline

Theresa Bartels’s production volume for the past 3 year period Q1 ’24 Q1 2024 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2024): $1.1M Q2 ’24 Q2 2024 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2024): $2.7M Q3 ’24 Q3 2024 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2024): $1.1M Q4 ’24 Q4 2024 (Oct 1–Dec 31, 2024): $1.1M Q1 ’25 Q1 2025 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2025): $875K Q2 ’25 Q2 2025 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2025): $786K Q3 ’25 Q3 2025 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2025): $2.5M Q4 ’25 Q4 2025 (Oct 1–Dec 31, 2025): $812K Q1 ’26 Q1 2026 (Jan 1–Mar 31, 2026): $1.1M Q2 ’26 Q2 2026 (Apr 1–Jun 30, 2026): $814K Q3 ’26 Q3 2026 (Jul 1–Sep 30, 2026): $260K Q1 2024 Total Sales $1.1M Q2 2024 Total Sales $2.7M Q3 2024 Total Sales $1.1M Q4 2024 Total Sales $1.1M Q1 2025 Total Sales $875K Q2 2025 Total Sales $786K Q3 2025 Total Sales $2.5M Q4 2025 Total Sales $812K Q1 2026 Total Sales $1.1M Q2 2026 Total Sales $814K Q3 2026 Total Sales $260K

Sales volume is shown for complete quarters only.

Ratings & Reviews
5.0 (4)

blasfamrg2014
Aug 6, 2021

A special thank you to Theresa and her team. They were there for me from start to finish... I am new to the Indy area and Theresa's compassion, familiarity & dedication got my family into the perfect home... Thank you Theresa Bartels!

Zillow Verified

zuser20170301095604798
Dec 31, 2020

Theresa was proactive in finding the right house for us. She let us know if she saw anything concerning in a house and did not push us but helped us along the way.

Zillow Verified

zuser20190624135926176
May 8, 2020

I and my wife worked with Theresa to purchase our first home in Brownsburg and really cannot say enough good things about her.
While the process of homebuying was much more difficult than we had imagined, based on the levels of competitiveness, Theresa gave us excellent guidance, unflagging availability, and deep knowledge about a wide range of homes that we looked at. She helped us narrow down what kind of home we were looking for and was patient as we dragged her through dozens of open houses. Based on our input (budget, ideal home, ideal location, school district), Theresa provided ideas on neighborhoods that might fit our wants/needs and what type of home we might expect to find within our budget.
She is knowledgeable, approachable, personable, endlessly patient, and incredibly generous with her time (including mornings, evenings, and weekends over the course of several months).
Most important to us, Theresa was always honest with us about what she thought about each property, was always available and helpful, and we always felt that she truly had our best interests at heart.
She answered every question and explained every form and every part of the process clearly and thoroughly. Buying a home is challenging but working with Theresa made it as painless and straightforward as possible.
In the future, if we ever decide to move, we will definitely use Theresa again to both sell our home and find a new one. We highly recommend her!

Zillow Verified

carl duke08
Aug 26, 2015

Theresa Bartels worked night and day (literally) to ensure my family found the house we were looking for. She went and saw I don't know how many houses with us, always being patient and listening to our desires and likes/dislikes. She was very easy to get in touch with, and I knew I could get a quick response via phone/text/email. Theresa is also very knowledgeable of the Greater Indianapolis housing market, and proved that with her very accurate estimates on what we could expect in different subdivisions throughout multiple suburbs. After the experience we had with Theresa, I know for a fact we will always use her in the future for our real estate needs.

Zillow Verified

Professional Info

Brokerage

The Indy Realty Shop
8614 Wildview Ct
Indianapolis, IN 46278

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
IN RB14042556

Specialties

  • Age-restricted communities
  • First-time buyers
  • Flipping & rehab
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Recreation & Vacation
  • Relocation

Top Cities *

Indianapolis

  • 23 sales past 3 years
  • 81 days on market
  • $275K median price

Noblesville

  • 4 sales past 3 years
  • 27 days on market
  • $320K median price

Lebanon

  • 3 sales past 3 years
  • $320K median price

*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.