Paige Pennington

Keller Williams High Country

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
I work with both buyers and sellers throughout the High Country, from those searching for a mountain getaway where their family can make memories for years to come, to people putting down roots and making this incredible community their full-time home. I also understand that selling a home can be just as personal. Whether it’s a place filled with years of memories or simply time for something new, I care deeply about making sure my clients feel heard, supported, and well represented throughout the process.

There is nowhere else I would rather sell real estate. I genuinely love the High Country and everything that makes living here special: the mountains, the small communities, the people, and the connection to the outdoors. I believe that knowing and loving this area makes me better at helping others find their place here and better at telling the story of the homes I’m trusted to sell.

My approach to real estate is personal, honest, and hands-on. I want my clients to feel like they have someone in their corner who truly cares about the outcome, not just someone guiding them through a transaction.

Outside of real estate, you’ll usually find me sewing or knitting, working in the garden, or exploring the mountains with my two dogs. This is home for me, and getting to help other people make it home too is one of my favorite parts of what I do.
Highlights *
42
Recent sales
$125K - $1.6M
Price range
$323K
Median price

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
411 Apple Vly
Zionville, NC 28698
9/30/2026 $221,625 Buyer
8977 Rose Hollow Ave
Newland, NC 28657
9/11/2026 $190,000 Seller
61 Rocky Pkwy
Banner Elk, NC 28604
9/4/2026 $185,000 Seller
552 N Fork Rd
Burnsville, NC 28714
7/29/2026 $349,000 Buyer
7039 Joe Bowman Ave
Newland, NC 28657
7/20/2026 $295,000 Buyer

Ratings & Reviews
5.0 (21)

sbaumeister2
Sep 9, 2026

Paige was absolutely amazing!! We were purchasing a property out of state and closing remotely. Paige made the process seamless and eased any of our worries. I would highly recommend working with Paige for your next real estate purchase in the High Country!!

Source: Zillow

Stacey Baumeister
Banner Elk, NC - Sep 9, 2026

Paige was absolutely amazing!! We were purchasing a property out of state and closing remotely. Paige made the process seamless and eased any of our worries. I would highly recommend working with Paige for your next real estate purchase in the High Country!!

Source: Google

Holly Shahan
Aug 6, 2026

I was an out of state buyer who was connected with Paige Pennington’s information. I had no idea what a Godsend she would be to me in this challenging process of trying to find a second home in somewhat unfamiliar territory and while being states away.

At first I was looking for a bit of help and guidance as I was beginning my searches and research in the area and she ended up sticking by my side for the next two years!

I could always count on her to answer promptly, thoroughly, and honestly. She was very supportive and attentive to my needs and concerns in my hunt for a home. She was a wealth of knowledge when it came to the landscape and communities of North Carolina that I had to learn, coming from out of state, and always seemed to have a contact of some sort to point me in the right direction for whatever I needed.

Working together while being so far apart required so much patience and excellent communication - Paige always exceeded my expectations with both. Not only is she professional, educated, well-connected, and all around phenomenal at what she does, but she has the passion and the heart to match it. She always made sure to help me feel taken care of and at ease and like she truly cared about the end result. Working with her left me feeling like I wasn’t just another client to her but rather, a friend.

While I am relieved and overjoyed to have finally found what she has been helping me search for for so long, there is a piece of me that is genuinely sad our journey has come to an end! I could not imagine finding anyone better and I highly recommend her to anyone with their real estate needs.

Source: Zillow

Lori Paquette
Burnsville, NC - Aug 6, 2026

I was an out of state buyer who was connected with Paige Pennington’s information. I had no idea what a Godsend she would be to me in this challenging process of trying to find a second home in somewhat unfamiliar territory and while being states away. At first I was looking for a bit of help and guidance as I was beginning my searches and research in the area and she ended up sticking by my side for the next two years! I could always count on her to answer promptly, thoroughly, and honestly. She was very supportive and attentive to my needs and concerns in my hunt for a home. She was a wealth of knowledge when it came to the landscape and communities of North Carolina that I had to learn, coming from out of state, and always seemed to have a contact of some sort to point me in the right direction for whatever I needed. Working together while being so far apart required so much patience and excellent communication - Paige always exceeded my expectations with both.

Source: Google

Sallie Smith
Jun 22, 2026

I can not express how absolutely wonderful Paige Pennington was to work with. She helped so much with the purchase of our townhome. She is responsive, knowledgeable, detail oriented, and always available. She met with us to show a property and from that point forward she guided us through the process and stayed in constant contact with us. She was able to tell us things about the property which we would not have known or thought to ask and gave us detailed information and reminders for completing the closing. She’s awesome!

Source: Zillow

Professional Info

Brokerage

Keller Williams High Country
774 East King Street
Boone, NC 28607

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
NC 353607

Awards

  • Top 5 Agent in KWHC

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Investment & property management
  • Luxury properties
  • Recreation & Vacation

Hobbies

  • Arts & Crafts
  • Gardening
  • Nature

Education

Milligan Univeristy
Bachelor’s Degree, Communications

Top Cities *

Banner Elk

  • 5 sales past 3 years
  • 134 days on market
  • $415K median price

Boone

  • 5 sales past 3 years
  • 30 days on market
  • $395K median price

Sugar Mountain

  • 5 sales past 3 years
  • $210K median price

*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.