- Agent Pronto
- Ohio
- Youngstown
- Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney
Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?
- 231
- Recent sales
- $10K - $1.95M
- Price range
- $175K
- Median price
- 23
- Years experience
Recent Listings & Sales
| Address | Sold Date | Sold Price | Represented |
|---|---|---|---|
|
361 Hilltop Blvd
Canfield, OH 44406
|
11/9/2026 | $254,000 | Buyer |
|
281 Stewart Rd
Salem, OH 44460
|
10/23/2026 | $225,000 | Buyer |
|
1020 Water St
Newton Falls, OH 44444
|
10/14/2026 | $145,000 | Seller |
|
2850 Vollmer Dr
Austintown, OH 44511
|
10/13/2026 | $203,500 | Seller |
|
1558 Thalia Ave
Youngstown, OH 44514
|
10/8/2026 | $102,300 | Buyer |
Transaction History *
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 56
- Total Value
- $14,621,507
- Median Sale Price
- $221,250
- Price Range
- $25K - $1.2M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 25
- Total Value
- $4,864,971
- Median Sale Price
- $160,000
- Price Range
- $30K - $690K
Sales Volume Timeline
Sales volume is shown for complete quarters only.
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 103
- Total Value
- $23,594,657
- Median Sale Price
- $185,500
- Price Range
- $22K - $1.2M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 64
- Total Value
- $13,338,771
- Median Sale Price
- $167,700
- Price Range
- $20K - $1.95M
Sales Volume Timeline
Sales volume is shown for complete quarters only.
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 137
- Total Value
- $28,331,157
- Median Sale Price
- $179,500
- Price Range
- $10K - $1.2M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 94
- Total Value
- $19,110,171
- Median Sale Price
- $168,950
- Price Range
- $20K - $1.95M
Sales Volume Timeline
Sales volume is shown for complete quarters only.
Ratings & Reviews
4.9
(129)
Reviewers say
Reviewers repeatedly praise Tibitha’s responsiveness, market knowledge, clear communication, and patient, personal guidance through buying and selling. They describe her as professional, trustworthy, hardworking, and attentive to their needs, often making complex transactions feel smoother and less stressful.
The term realtor cannot describe her abilities, attention to detail and loyalty towards her clients, a hidden gem in today's market!
My home purchase was seamless, her staff mirrored her as well. What a gem in today's world.Simply put, beyond "Outstanding". Thanks Tiby, you Fricken Rock!!
Mark P
RealSatisfied Verified
Tibitha was great would fully recommend using her and could be more satisfied
RealSatisfied Verified
Tibitha was great right from the start. Always available. Pays attention to what you are looking for, and understands when you don't like something. Even calmed me down when I was overwhelmed. My overall opinion is that I certainly made the right choice by choosing to work with Tibitha !!
RealSatisfied Verified
We loved Tibitha. She was supportive every step of the way. She recommended great junk people for prepping out house and getting rid of old stuff, and she got beautiful pictures of our place. Our house went pending within the first couple days. She even went out of her way on a Friday afternoon to help us get in touch with people when we had a roadblock. I would use her again.
RealSatisfied Verified
Very knowledgeable and caring and so very helpful assisting with the sale of my house and buying another house was always available to look at properties when trying to buy another house helped me through this transition tremendously helped me sell my house fast and also helped me find another house quickly as well. Tibby is very motivated very kind, amazing, trustworthy, honest and so much more. She was a blessing in disguise and I appreciate her so very much. She is great at what she does and very smart this girl has it going on and more. God bless this sweet soul.
RealSatisfied Verified
Professional Info
Brokerage
6715 Tippecanoe Rd Blah A Suite 102
Canfield, OH 44406
Licensed
OH 2003008663
Awards
- #1 State of Ohio CENTURY 21 in 2024-Units Sold
- CENTURION 2021,2022,2023,2024,2025
- #2 State of Ohio CENTURY 21 2025-Units Sold
- Rookie of the Year 2003/4
- Proud Top Agent in my Brokerage 2009-2025
Specialties
- Age-restricted communities
- First-time buyers
- Flipping & rehab
- Foreclosures & Short sales
- Investment & property management
- Luxury properties
- Military
- Recreation & Vacation
- Relocation
Designations
- SRES®
Hobbies
- Nature
Top Cities *
Youngstown
- 69 sales past 3 years
- 40 days on market
- $151K median price
Warren
- 28 sales past 3 years
- 54 days on market
- $160K median price
Austintown
- 27 sales past 3 years
- 40 days on market
- $188K median price
Service Areas (59 cities)
*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.