Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney

Results is the name of the game we asked Tibitha to put together a puzzle of circumstances that had to be taken into consideration. She made selling our property possible for a large group of buyers. We are glad to say that we can share our wonderful Realtor, Tibitha Matheney with the rest of the world. Thank you Tibitha

Having Tibitha Matheney as my Realtor was an amazing experience. She is excellent at her job and gives 110% all the time. She is so knowledgeable and listens to your wants and needs. She provides pertinent feedback and ideas to help market your property in the best way. On the market less than two weeks!
I would definitely recomment Tibitha to ALL my friends and family. When buying or selling I always use Tibitha.

Second time using Tib's expertise, sold our home quickly and above ask! The best!

Tibitha was very helpful and understanding of my needs. She was easy to work with and navigated my schedule perfectly. I could not have done it without her !

I would have never got my house 🏠 if it wasn't for excellent determination Tibetha represent leadership in everything she does and honesty to her job she is a strong leader beyond knowledge I want to thank her for giving me a lifetime of happiness for making the house that I wanted possible she is above and beyond and should be everyone realtor thank you again Tibetha so proud to have you as a realtor but important as a friend

Tibitha was very helpful and knowledgeable which was very important because we were settling an estate. We were not familiar with the area and Tibitha did a great job guiding us through the sale of the property. She was great about communicating especially responding to my questions. I would highly recommend her.

Tibitha was a wonderful agent. We would definitely use her again.

Tibitha went well beyond our expectations.

Tibitha was great. I would highly recommend her knowledge and skills to anyone. If I am ever in the market to buy or sell I will definitely call her again.

I recommend Tibitha because she was engaged with us from day one, the fit between client and realtor was as important to her as what we were looking for in a home and the circumstances surrounding our move. She was efficient and professional and all the while very down to earth and friendly. She approached every negotiation and bump in the road very logically, helping keep emotions out of the equation. She continually demonstrated our satisfaction was her priority. If you are looking for a similar experience, I recommend you working with Tibitha Matheney.

Tibitha was incredible! We were first time home buyers and had no idea what to do. She walked is through every step and explained things as many times as needed. She truly cares about getting us the house we wanted.

Working with Tibitha was an absolute pleasure, and I can't recommend her enough. From the very beginning, it was clear she always had our best interest at heart, and made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free by truly taking the time to understand our needs and preferences. What impressed us the most was her proactive approach, as she was always one step ahead and was very quick to get us quotes and recommendations for everything we needed, even before we had the time to think about some of these things ourselves. She knew exactly when things needed to be done and kept everything moving forward. We never had to chase anyone down because she handled everything with such precision and speed. If you're looking for an agent who is organized, energetic, and dedicated to fighting for you, Tib is the perfect choice!

Tibitha is very professional and on point. She knew exactly how to prepare the home for sale, she new how to get the right pictures, and she was communicating with us on a daily basis. I will never work with anyone else. We have been using Tibitha's services for over 15 years.

When Larry passed away we were devistated, not just because Larry was a close personal friend, but also because he was assisting us in exactly the way that we needed to find a new home under very dire circumstances. When Tibby took over she graciously and respectfully emmulated the work that Larry was doing for us and we are eternally grateful.

We had an exceptional experience working with Tibitha Matheney when buying our home. She was incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Tibitha went above and beyond to ensure we found the perfect home, always keeping our best interests in mind. Her professionalism and dedication are unmatched. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a top-notch realtor!

Tibby is great. Needed some guidance & help with my mothers house. Paint and cleanup, she had a guy. We did what she suggested in the house. House was under contract in 3/4 days. Thank you Tibby.

As first-time home buyers, my husband and I couldn't have asked for a better experience than working with Tibitha. She was patient, thorough, and made sure we understood every part of the process. What truly set her apart was the way she went the extra mile to help us—she informed us about a home-buying grant that we hadn’t even known existed, and it turned out to be a lifesaver for us financially!

Tibitha’s knowledge and expertise, combined with her dedication to our needs, made the entire journey smooth and stress-free. She was always available to answer questions, provided expert advice, and guided us through each step, ensuring we felt confident in our decisions. Her negotiation skills helped us secure a great deal, and she truly cared about finding the perfect home for us.

We highly recommend Tibitha to anyone, especially first-time buyers. She’s not just a realtor, but a true partner in the home-buying process!

I could not have hoped for any experience better than what we had with Tibi-both buying and selling.

I enjoy working with her. She was very good at what she does. I would recommend her again and I probably will use her again with other properties. I'd like to thank her for being so understanding thank you.

I recently had the pleasure of working with Tibitha and Nicole to sell my house, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and dedication were evident from start to finish. They provided invaluable market insights, effectively marketed my property, and handled all negotiations with skill and care. Their communication was excellent, keeping me informed every step of the way. Thanks to their expertise, my house sold quickly and at a great price. I highly recommend Tibitha and Nicole to anyone looking to buy or sell a home—they truly exceeded my expectations!

Tibby got us a deal on the home we bought that we couldn't even imagine. As first time home buyers she was there every step of the way to explain what things were happening, why things were happening, and next steps. In the end, we got a home we loved and are SO excited to move into.

Tibi is a bad ass.

It was wonderful working with Tibitha, she was easy to communicate with and I was very impressed with her work ethic and attention to detail when moving through the selling process. I would highly recommend her.

I worked with Tibitha multiple times, and all I can say is she is amazing! She has gone above and beyond for myself and family everytime we've worked together. I highly recommend!

I worked with Tibitha Matheney following my mother's passing in Boardman, Ohio to help sell her condominium. I live out of state in Georgia so I expected this to be quite challenging; however, with Tibitha's help the sale of the condo was smooth and easy. She is extremely knowledgeable regarding local contacts you may need such as title agents and handyman services. Her knowledge of the local housing market was vast, and she researched well. Our property had an offer we approved within 24 hours of being listed! I highly recommend Tibitha for all your realtor needs.