1. Agent Pronto
  2. Ohio
  3. Youngstown
  4. Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney

Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney

Century 21 Lakeside Realty Canfield

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
Licensed since 2003, I work full-time and proudly serve Mahoning, Trumbull, and Columbiana Counties! I work with both sellers and buyers. Selling? I communicate well, assess your home in person, gather detailed information, consult and advise, then market strongly and negotiate on your behalf. Buying? The first step is a buyer consultation to discuss the process, your goals, and the steps from start to finish. If we fit, we can assemble our buying team and dedicate time and effort to finding you a great home, then negotiate on your behalf to obtain the needed terms. Using skills I have developed from nearly 2,000 home sales makes game planning and negotiation my specialty. Smooth and successful is the goal. You are my priority. Let’s talk!
Highlights *
234
Recent sales
$10K-$1.95M
Price range
$168K
Median price
23
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
177 Willard Ave SE
Warren, OH 44483
8/18/2026 $133,500 Buyer
180 Clarencedale Ave
Youngstown, OH 44512
8/10/2026 $80,000 Buyer
4260 Wedgewood Dr
Youngstown, OH 44511
7/30/2026 $201,000 Buyer
3958 Marcella Dr
North Royalton, OH 44133
7/28/2026 $690,000 Buyer
5179 Willow Crest Ave
Austintown, OH 44515
7/23/2026 $190,500 Buyer

Transaction History *

Seller Deals

Total Deals
143
Total Value
$28,921,557
Median Sale Price
$175,000
Price Range
$10K - $1.2M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
95
Total Value
$19,066,466
Median Sale Price
$168,000
Price Range
$20K - $1.95M

Sales Volume Timeline

Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney’s production volume for the past 3 year period Q3 ’23 Q3 2023: $2.1M Q4 ’23 Q4 2023: $3.4M Q1 ’24 Q1 2024: $2.2M Q2 ’24 Q2 2024: $4.3M Q3 ’24 Q3 2024: $2.5M Q4 ’24 Q4 2024: $6.4M Q1 ’25 Q1 2025: $2.1M Q2 ’25 Q2 2025: $3.7M Q3 ’25 Q3 2025: $5.2M Q4 ’25 Q4 2025: $6.7M Q1 ’26 Q1 2026: $1.9M Q2 ’26 Q2 2026: $5.2M Q3 ’26 Q3 2026: $2.3M Q3 2023 Total Sales $2.1M Q4 2023 Total Sales $3.4M Q1 2024 Total Sales $2.2M Q2 2024 Total Sales $4.3M Q3 2024 Total Sales $2.5M Q4 2024 Total Sales $6.4M Q1 2025 Total Sales $2.1M Q2 2025 Total Sales $3.7M Q3 2025 Total Sales $5.2M Q4 2025 Total Sales $6.7M Q1 2026 Total Sales $1.9M Q2 2026 Total Sales $5.2M Q3 2026 (Jul 1-Aug 29) Total Sales $2.3M

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (123)

Kimmy J
Boardman, OH - Aug 28, 2026

We had an outstanding experience working with Tibitha. She helped us sell our house quickly while making the entire process as smooth and stress-free as possible. What really stood out was her ability to navigate some challenging appraisal issues. She was able to help us get a structural assessment of the basement scheduled very quickly. She was proactive, knowledgeable, responsive, and persistent in working through the complications and keeping everything on track to get the deal closed. She also was able to successfully negotiate on our behalf, which saved us thousands of dollars. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for an agent who knows how to get the job done!

Verified by RealSatisfied

Jack Inga
East Palestine, OH - Aug 16, 2026

Having Tibitha on your side made everything easier
I recommend Tibitha %100

Verified by RealSatisfied

Cheryl Medina
Youngstown, OH - Jul 31, 2026

As first-time homebuyers, we had absolutely no clue what we were doing, but Tibi made the entire process feel so much less overwhelming. From the beginning, she was patient, kind, knowledgeable, and always took the time to explain things and guide us every step of the way.

When we finally found the house we loved, Tibi was just as excited as we were and wrapped me in the biggest, most heartfelt mom hug. Then she moved mountains to help make sure we got our home! That moment meant so much to us and truly showed how personally invested she was in helping make our dream of becoming homeowners a reality.

We are beyond grateful for everything Tibi did for us and could not have asked for a better realtor to guide us through our first home-buying experience. We would recommend her to anyone, especially first-time homebuyers!

Verified by RealSatisfied

Austin Beck
Youngstown, OH - Jul 30, 2026

Tibitha's dedication to helping me find my first home was way above expectations. She over exceeded expectations when helping me find EXACTLY what I wanted, and helped me explain little details I didn't know about, she is truly for her customers and I will be using her again. I can't thank her enough for all she did for me and ALL of my family she's helped get their forever homes!!

Verified by RealSatisfied

Greg and Laura Kiddon
Austintown, OH - Jun 25, 2026

This was our first experience selling a house. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Tibitha Matheney!

Tibi was with us every step of the way. From the moment we met her, we felt comfortable with her. She walked through our house and help us decide which things were important to address and which were not. We were clueless; thank goodness for Tibi! She helped us choose an asking price and explained her thought process. She answered all of our questions in a concise way (and we had a lot of questions). She even had an open house the day after the house was listed!

We live hours away from where we were selling. Tibi even helped by letting workers into the house. Pretty much everything for the sale was handled online. Tibi worked hard to get the asking price for our house. And she went through the closing documents line by line with us so we fully understood everything.

We highly encourage anyone who is looking for an honest, hardworking realtor to consider Tibitha Matheney

Verified by RealSatisfied

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Lakeside Realty Canfield
6715 Tippecanoe Rd Blah A Suite 102
Canfield, OH 44406

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
OH 2003008663

Awards

  • #1 State of Ohio CENTURY 21 in 2024-Units Sold
  • CENTURION 2021,2022,2023,2024,2025
  • #2 State of Ohio CENTURY 21 2025-Units Sold
  • Rookie of the Year 2003/4
  • Proud Top Agent in my Brokerage 2009-2025

Specialties

  • Age-restricted communities
  • First-time buyers
  • Flipping & rehab
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Investment & property management
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Recreation & Vacation
  • Relocation

Designations

  • SRES®

Hobbies

  • Nature

Top Cities *

Youngstown

  • 72 sales past 3 years
  • 43 days on market
  • $150K median price

Warren

  • 29 sales past 3 years
  • 46 days on market
  • $130K median price

Austintown

  • 27 sales past 3 years
  • 46 days on market
  • $185K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.