1. Agent Pronto
  2. Ohio
  3. Youngstown
  4. Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney

Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney

Century 21 Lakeside Realty Canfield
4.9 (115 reviews)

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
I am a full time agent and I try to work around my clients' schedules! I work in Mahoning, Columbiana, and Trumbull Counties. I have worked hard to earn additional credentials to increase my education in my field.

I make it a point to assist any potential buyers with help to obtain a pre-approval with a lender, the golden ticket to home ownership. I ask that my clients make the commitment to getting pre-approved, but in return I dedicate time and effort into finding you a great home.

Sellers, I work hard to assess your home fairly, making sure to get detailed information and taking the time needed to price your asset at the best price point the market will react to. My goal is to make your process one that gets you to be able to move on with your life, this is one of the largest investments you have!

I love helping people buy homes and sell homes. Let me help you make your real estate dreams and goals a reality!
Highlights *
245
Recent sales
$10K-$1.95M
Price range
$165K
Median price
23
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address Sold Date Sold Price Represented
163 N Chestnut Ave
Niles, OH 44446
5/12/2026 $165,500 Buyer
324 Neff Dr
Canfield, OH 44406
5/8/2026 $325,000 Seller
3555 W South Range Rd
Columbiana, OH 44408
5/7/2026 $270,000 Seller
3555 W South Range Rd
Columbiana, OH 44408
5/7/2026 $270,000 Buyer
336 Willard Ave SE
Warren, OH 44483
4/30/2026 $130,000 Buyer

Transaction History *

Seller Deals

Total Deals
145
Total Value
$27,967,450
Median Sale Price
$165,000
Price Range
$10K - $1.2M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
102
Total Value
$19,496,495
Median Sale Price
$164,000
Price Range
$20K - $1.95M

Sales Volume Timeline

Tibitha (Tibi) Matheney’s production volume for the past 3 year period Q2 ’23 Q2 2023: $2M Q3 ’23 Q3 2023: $2.7M Q4 ’23 Q4 2023: $3.4M Q1 ’24 Q1 2024: $2.3M Q2 ’24 Q2 2024: $4.4M Q3 ’24 Q3 2024: $2.5M Q4 ’24 Q4 2024: $7.3M Q1 ’25 Q1 2025: $2.1M Q2 ’25 Q2 2025: $4.2M Q3 ’25 Q3 2025: $5.4M Q4 ’25 Q4 2025: $6.7M Q1 ’26 Q1 2026: $2.4M Q2 ’26 Q2 2026: $2M Q2 2023 Total Sales $2M Q3 2023 Total Sales $2.7M Q4 2023 Total Sales $3.4M Q1 2024 Total Sales $2.3M Q2 2024 Total Sales $4.4M Q3 2024 Total Sales $2.5M Q4 2024 Total Sales $7.3M Q1 2025 Total Sales $2.1M Q2 2025 Total Sales $4.2M Q3 2025 Total Sales $5.4M Q4 2025 Total Sales $6.7M Q1 2026 Total Sales $2.4M Q2 2026 (Apr 1-May 23) Total Sales $2M

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (115)

Morgan Gray
Mineral Ridge, OH - May 22, 2026

We had a wonderful experience working with Tibi! As first-time homebuyers, we were unsure of the process and had plenty of questions and stress along the way. Tibi was incredibly patient and took the time to explain everything clearly, always making sure we felt comfortable and informed. She supported us through every step from connecting us with lenders to coordinating inspections and handling repairs and consistently went above and beyond what we expected. She was also amazing with our toddlers, which made the whole experience even smoother for our family. We’re so grateful we chose to work with her.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Briana Porter
Niles, OH - May 19, 2026

Tibitha was overall amazing. She was attentive to all my needs and questions, she was informative and patient. It felt like I was dealing with a friend, Very personable. From the moment I reached out to her at the start of my journey of finding the perfect home for my family, she was always very responsive. So much so that when she was on vacation ( a time that was meant for her and her family ) she still made a point to inform me, update me on negotiations & answer any questions I had. She made my first time buying a home a wonderful experience!!!

Verified by RealSatisfied

Brandee Osso
Youngstown, OH - Feb 26, 2026

Tibitha is an Excellent realtor! She is very knowledgeable about every aspect when it comes to selling and buying! We would choose her again and again!

Verified by RealSatisfied

James & Ryan Halicki
Warren, OH - Feb 6, 2026

Verified by RealSatisfied

Beverly Laraway
Austintown, OH - Jan 1, 2026

Tibitha coordinated the sale of our home in the timeframe we requested for the price we wanted. She was our realtor for the purchase of our new home, keeping in mind our wish list. We recommend Tibitha for both purchasing and selling a home. She is professional, knowledgeable, and patient.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Lakeside Realty Canfield
6715 Tippecanoe Rd A102
Canfield, OH 44406

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
OH 2003008663

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Military

Designations

  • SRES®

Top Cities *

Youngstown

  • 73 sales past 3 years
  • 41 days on market
  • $151K median price

Warren

  • 30 sales past 3 years
  • 46 days on market
  • $127K median price

Austintown

  • 27 sales past 3 years
  • 42 days on market
  • $185K median price

Service Areas (58 cities)

Austintown, OH Beloit, OH Berlin Center, OH Boardman, OH Bolindale, OH Brookfield, OH Calcutta, OH Campbell, OH Canfield, OH Canton, OH Champion Heights, OH Churchill, OH Columbiana, OH Cortland, OH Craig Beach, OH Diamond, OH East Liverpool, OH East Palestine, OH Ellsworth, OH Fowler, OH Geneva, OH Girard, OH Hilltop, OH Howland Center, OH Hubbard, OH Lake Milton, OH Leavittsburg, OH Leetonia, OH Lisbon, OH Lordstown, OH Lowellville, OH Maplewood Park, OH Masury, OH McDonald, OH McKinley Heights, OH Mineral Ridge, OH Morgandale, OH New Middletown, OH New Springfield, OH Newton Falls, OH Niles, OH North Jackson, OH North Lima, OH Orwell, OH Pepper Pike, OH Poland, OH Salem, OH Sebring, OH South Canal, OH Southington, OH Streetsboro, OH Struthers, OH Vienna, OH Warren, OH Wellsville, OH Windham, OH Woodworth, OH Youngstown, OH

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.