February 2026 brought sharp month-over-month shifts in Old Agoura, with the typical home value dropping about 25.9% to roughly $2,187,500 even as the median list price jumped 17.9% to about $2,799,000, reflecting a gap between what sellers are asking and where values are trending. Homes also stayed on the market far longer than the prior month, with median days on market climbing over 200% to 251 days. Inventory tightened to just 1 active listing, and only 1 new listing came on the market, while 3 homes were in pending status.
Looking at the past year for context, typical home values in Old Agoura are down about 28.9% year over year, contrasting with Agoura Hills overall, where values near $1,425,000 are up about 8.4%. Inventory has fallen dramatically compared with last year, dropping about 90.9%, and new listings declined around 91.7%. Pending sales are also lower than a year ago, down about 25%.
Despite slower sales timelines and softer values, Old Agoura is still categorized as a seller's market, and no recent homes have sold above list, with the average sale-to-list ratio near 0.95. Looking ahead to March 2026, projections show typical values easing toward about $1,806,250 while the median list price could edge above $3,011,250 and active inventory may temporarily reach 0. In this kind of shifting environment, both buyers and sellers can benefit from Agent Pronto’s help in finding an agent who understands Old Agoura’s numbers and trends.
