Over the past year, typical home values in Allendale have inched down about 1.5 percent to roughly $100,500. That is well below the broader Jacksonville figure of about $300,000, highlighting Allendale’s lower price point. Pending sales have fallen more sharply year over year, down a little over 41 percent, while new listings have been cut in half.
Recent monthly data shows some notable shifts. The median list price slid over 8 percent from the prior month to around $147,000, and inventory dropped nearly 27 percent to just 11 homes, with only 11 new listings and 10 pending sales in March 2026.
Homes are taking time to sell, with a median of 95 days on market, even though that figure is down more than 42 percent from last month and up 90 percent from a year ago. Buyers may find some negotiating power, as the average sale-to-list ratio sits near 0.87 and no recent sales closed above asking, yet Allendale is still labeled a seller's market with a gauge of 11, helped by low supply and a projected dip in inventory to about 9 homes next month alongside a projected typical value near $97,750 and list price around $140,500. Whether buyers are seeking value or sellers are navigating these shifts, Agent Pronto can connect both sides with a local expert agent in Allendale.
