Year-over-year, Tuckahoe’s rolling three-month data shows prices pushing higher while supply has thinned. The median list price is up about 7% compared with the same period last year, signaling sellers are testing stronger pricing. Active listings, however, are down by roughly a third, pointing to fewer options for buyers.
Looking at the latest rolling three-month period ending in June 2026, the median list price sits around $389,000 with just four homes on the market. New listings are holding steady compared with last year, but the smaller pool of active listings suggests that properties may be getting absorbed more quickly when they do appear.
Historical patterns over the past few years show Tuckahoe shifting between periods of abundant inventory and tighter conditions, with months of supply swinging from about 2 months in late 2023 to more than 9 months in mid-2024, and back to roughly 6 months at several points. Sale prices have also moved around, from about $246,500 in mid-2023 to $400,000 by mid-2025, illustrating how quickly conditions can change in a small market. With the overall market gauge still pointing to a seller’s market, both buyers trying to secure a home and sellers aiming to price correctly can benefit from Agent Pronto’s help connecting them with a local agent who understands these shifts.
