Cici Carter
Keller Williams First Coast Realty

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
94 recent sales
$130K - $750K
SFR®
68 days on market
21 years experience
About
With licenses in both Florida and Georgia and over 20 years of experience, I bring unmatched expertise and dedication to every transaction. I have been the top-producing agent at Keller Williams First Coast Realty for four consecutive years—leading in both closed volume and units. In 2025 alone, I closed 46 sales totaling $15.9 million. My clients value my tech-savvy approach, sharp negotiation skills, and unwavering focus on customer service. A Cum Laude graduate with a B.S. in Information Technology from the University of North Florida, I am always seeking new ways to elevate the buying and selling experience. When results matter, experience counts. I would love the opportunity to partner with you in your home purchase or sale!

Ratings & Reviews

Mariane Smith

Cici has been an awesome realtor. We are moving across the country so we did this process virtually and Cici has made it seamless. If you need someone that’s responsive and will help you in the process of buying a house in the GA/FL area, I recommend Cici as she is also licensed in both states!

Wanda Griggs

We were looking to sell our home quickly and found Cici Carter on the Fox Creek neighborhood FB page where she has sold several homes. Her knowledge, professionalism and expertise in the real estate market convinced my husband and I that we made the right choice. She was always available and very attentive to our needs and made the selling process go smoothly. Cici's bright and bubbly personality was an added bonus! If you're looking to buy or sell your home we highly recommend Cici and her team!

Diane and Rudy Maul

Cici is an excellent real estate agent and provides both outstanding professional and personal service. She focuses on building lasting relationships and not just transactions. Ask her to sing for you.

K. Vazquez

My husband and I worked with Cici and her team to buy a home and then a year later we had to sell it due to a forced work relocation. Her level of professionalism and expertise were outstanding. If you need a realtor, call Cici!

B. Norman

What can I say…Cici was s the absolute best realtor in the area. She has worked with me for the past 3 years before I found a property that I loved and is a good fit for my needs. During my home buying journey, she remained consistent. CiCi reached out to me often with new listings with out pressure. When I decided to build my home, Cici worked out specifics of the purchase contract and saved me 💰. She was highly recommended to me and I highly recommended her to others.

L. Burke

It's a pleasure working with Cici!! This is our second closing with her and the team and they have been amazing!! We are working on closing #3 now!!

S. Williams

Cici and her team (Ms. Adesina) were amazing throughout the entire first home purchase process for my husband and me. They stepped-in and assisted us ways we didn't expect, which is always nice. I could not have asked for a better realtor who is so personable, professional and attentive...what a God send :). I would highly recommend Cici and her team to anyone at any stage in their real estate journey; I know we'll definitely keep her and her team in ours not only as our real estate team, but as friends!

George Thompson

The Cici Carter, Real Estate Agent @ Keller Williams is the consummate Professional. Provided the highest level of quality customer service. Highly recommended.

Dr. Hollie Kelly

PATIENT! Professional. Experienced. Trustworthy. Knowledgable. Has built a very thorough team around her. Dealing with 2 retired Marines, CiCi KNOWS this lane and operates in EXCELLENCE! Stop wasting time -hire her yesterday!

Professional Info

Brokerage

Keller Williams First Coast Realty
151 College Dr 14
Orange Park, FL 32065

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
FL BK3245330
GA 275832

Awards

  • Top Producer 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021
  • Agent Leadership Council

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Relocation

Designations

  • SFR®

Hobbies

  • Music
  • Reading
  • Volunteering

Education

University of North Florida
Bachelor’s Degree, Information Technology
2012 - 2017

Top Cities *

Jacksonville

  • 51 sales past 3 years
  • 76 days on market
  • $325K median price

Orange Park

  • 16 sales past 3 years
  • 77 days on market
  • $305K median price

Middleburg

  • 6 sales past 3 years
  • 68 days on market
  • $305K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.