Nicole Lovely

Century 21 Circle

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
15 recent sales
$140K - $630K
7 years experience
About
Nicole Galbreath was born, raised, and spent her entire life in Elkhart County. She has been serving Elkhart County and surrounding areas as a REALTOR since July of 2018. After 12 years of customer service, management and administrative assistance and 8 years of being a stay at home mom to her daughter, Bre and her son, Blane; she understands and displays the persistence, enthusiasm, and desire to help it takes to excel as a Real Estate Professional. Through her marriage to her firefighter husband, Chris, she has developed a new passion for helping those brave men and women who serve our country and community. Nicole delights in turning her clients' dreams and ideas into plans, that ultimately help them achieve their goals. She craves excitement, new experiences, new people, and new ideas which gives Nicole an edge in creative marketing.

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (55)

Haley Mitchell
Elkhart, IN - Aug 5, 2025

Nicole is upbeat, positive, efficient, and knowledgeable! She made buying and selling our first home smooth and simple!

Jaycie Rodriguez
Elkhart, IN - Aug 1, 2025

As first-time home buyers, we couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Nicole. She was absolutely fantastic—knowledgeable, patient, and always had our best interest in mind. She made the entire process feel less overwhelming and was there for us every step of the way. We’re so grateful for her help and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a great home buying experience.

Patti Vreugdenhil
Elkhart, IN - Mar 25, 2025

Nicole did an amazing job with the sale of our property. The ground was frozen so, she actually sold the house before we even got the sign in the ground! I believe it was four days total on the market before we had a qualified buyer make an offer. She helped us through every step and the entire process was very smooth.

Mandy Mayer
Goshen, IN - Sep 10, 2024

Nicole was knowledgeable about the comparative pricing in our area, and she understood our needs and expectations on the selling process. I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.

Jim Slaight
Elkhart, IN - Nov 28, 2023

Only agent I would consider. I have referred her and everyone I know was very happy.
My daughter used Nicole to list and purchase and Nicole went way above and beyond..

Candice R. Carter
Avilla, IN - Aug 15, 2023

Nicole handled the sale of my home with knowledge, patience and charisma!

Robin Shetler
Goshen, IN - Feb 14, 2023

Nicole was professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. She went above and beyond our expectations and made our buying experience a breeze. She's great to work with!

Bill Y.
Elkhart, IN - Sep 16, 2022

The agent we found via Agent Pronto, Nicole Galbreath, was exactly what we needed. Nicole is professional, personable and doggedly worked our home purchase to the end. She assertively advocated for us to ensure we didn't pay too much for anything. She connected us with home inspections services that saved us money and trouble later. She answered our questions or helped us get them, however simple or complex. She even helped us engage cleaning services for after the purchase. A very positive experience!

Todd
Elkhart, IN - Aug 30, 2022

Nicole immediately understood what I wanted and she didn't mess around with anything else. I knew she wouldn't waste my time.

Nicole always made sure I knew what was going on, where I was in the process and what had to be completed. Even through multiple changes during closing (because of seller), Nicole was on top of it. My lender, an outside lender, mentioned how well she did her job and would be happy to work with her again.

Susan Szybowicz
Bristol, IN - Jul 9, 2022

Nicole Galbreath was great! Always there to help answer my, sometimes silly, questions. She was polite and honest from the beginning. Very helpful and would def use her again if we ever want to move. (But I doubt we will)

Theresa
South Bend, IN - Nov 25, 2021

Nicole was great to work with! She was very helpful and supportive as well as professional yet personable. The sale was very quick and smooth. Nicole was very responsive and helpful when I had questions. Nicole was fantastic to work with. I will definitely refer her to my friends and family!

LeeAnn Daugherty
Louisville, IN - Nov 19, 2021

Nicole has been amazing through this whole buying process & I greatly appreciate her patience & timely response.

Brittany Carter
Leesburg, IN - Nov 4, 2021

Love her! Her attention to detail was great. She made sure our needs and wants were met. She was very helpful on helping us find a wonderful home that we are proud of. She did not seem concerned about her commission on our sale but more focused on making sure we had a great experience while making sure we got the house we fell in love with. She worked well with our lender and was great about making sure we were comfortable and knew what to expect through the entire process. Nicole went above and beyond to make sure that everything noted in the home inspection was addressed with the sellers so we would have no worries. I don't believe this process would have been as quick and smooth without her. She really treated us like family and we will never use any other realtor.

Scott and Caitlin
Elkhart, IN - Nov 3, 2021

We have worked with Nicole in the past and would not hesitate to work with her again or recommend her to friends and family. She is professional, prompt, thorough, fun, knowledgeable, trustworthy and kind. She makes sure to be available whenever her clients need her and goes to bat for them making sure they are treated fairly. We absolutely love Nicole and couldn’t be happier with our experience!

Dawn G
Mishawaka, IN - Oct 25, 2021

She was great to work with.

Christina Mitchell
Osceola, IN - Oct 7, 2021

It was an honor to have her as agent. I will always choose her. She knows her stuff and is knowledgeable and helped us during our first time owner’s experience.

Dustin
Elkhart, IN - Aug 12, 2021

Nicole helped us out big time in the heat of the bidding wars! She was always on it with any information we asked for at anytime of the day or night.. I will 100% recommend Nicole to anyone I come across looking to buy property..

Thanks again Nicole! We Love our new home!

Dustin and Danielle

Kyle S.
Elkhart, IN - Jul 15, 2021

She stuck with me through the entire process. I'd recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home. Nicole was very kind and was on top of everything that I asked!

Caitlin Frey
Elkhart, IN - May 9, 2021

Nicole was amazing, as always, from start to finish. When we decide to buy we will be using her again. We always recommend her to everyone who will listen!

Dom and Haley
Elkhart, IN - Feb 10, 2021

Nicole was an amazing agent! It was our first time buying a house and she was very diligent on explaining the process step-by-step! Our home buying process had many twists and turns and Nicole was able to navigate the best decisions and options for us! Nicole is very knowledgeable in in her field! Nicole was also able to make this seem less like a transaction and more personal! She was able to get us our home!!

Rebecca Kendall
Mishawaka, IN - Nov 7, 2020

Nicole did an outstanding job getting our home sold within 5 days of listing it. Things couldn't have went any smoother being we did a remote closing because we live out of state. I would and have reccomend her to family & friends. I wish she could have been our realtor in Florida as well and found us our new forever home.

Debbie Sweet
Elkhart, IN - Oct 5, 2020

Nicole did a great job for us. She is very knowledgeable and took the necessary time to explain what options best suited our needs. We highly recommend Nicole to our friends and family.

Chris Davis
Elkhart, IN - Oct 5, 2020

Nicole was a great agent to work with. She helped us see beyond the flaws of the house we noticed from living there daily, and gave us an opportunity to see it through the eyes of a new owner. That helped us sell with confidence and move into the next chapter of our life without constant anxiety about the house and chapter we had closed.

John Cornish
Elkhart, IN - Nov 27, 2019

Nicole I don’t believe I can say anything more positive about you. I just want you to know that I’m thankful from the bottom of my heart for everything you have done for Emily and I. You’re the best!!!

Scott and Caitlin
Elkhart, IN - Nov 22, 2019

Nicole came highly recommended from friends and family and we will now also highly recommend her. We can’t sing her praises enough! We had never sold a home before and had some major anxiety going into it, she calmed our nerves and handled everything amazingly. She made an experience we were fearful of enjoyable! She was prompt on corresponding with us and was extremely professional. We can’t wait to continue our buying journey with her!

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Circle
1001 Parkway Ave 17
Elkhart, IN 46516

Licensed

License Real Estate Agent
IN RB18001302

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Luxury properties
  • Relocation

Top Cities *

Goshen

  • 7 sales past 3 years
  • 18 days on market
  • $275K median price

Elkhart

  • 3 sales past 3 years
  • days on market
  • $277K median price

Bristol

  • 2 sales past 3 years
  • days on market
  • $220K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.