Amy Nienstedt
Carolina One Real Estate

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
61 recent sales
$180K - $700K
63 days on market
e-PRO®
15+ years experience
About

Amy is a 15 year residential real estate industry veteran and has represented hundreds of buyers and sellers in a wide array of real estate transactions. Her reputation for protecting her clients’ interests, savvy negotiation skills, uncompromising integrity, and “outside the box” marketing strategies are the hallmarks of her service. Exceptionally loyal clientele, personal referrals, and repeat business have formed the foundation of Amy’s career. So much so, that she was recently named “Summerville’s Favorite Real Estate Agent” by the readers of the Summerville Journal Scene.

A Charleston resident since 2004, Amy is an enthusiastic member of the community and enjoys gardening, baking, fishing the waters of the lowcountry, and showing clients the best that Charleston has to offer!

Ratings & Reviews
5.0

Keith H.
Summerville, SC
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.
Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

No written review provided.

S Pickrell

This was our second time working with Amy and we couldn’t be happier. Throughout our relocation to the area she was knowledgeable and patient with all of our questions. We enjoyed working with her so much that when we decided it was time to move again, she was the first call we made. She made us seem like we were her only client and went above and beyond for us in both selling our old home as well as finding our perfect place. I highly recommend her.

obryanadams

While searching for an agent, my wife and I needed to make sure the agent was relateable and took her job as our agent as serious as we took our dream of being joint homeowners. We went to Amy with one simple request. Make our buying experience as stressless as possible. She was successful at gauging us and helping us come to a decision that building was our best option.

We found out we were pregnant at the beginning of the build and had the baby right before moving in. It seemed like we only needed to worry about the baby, because Amy did everything allowed to ensure us a stress free build.

Amy makes me want to buy another house because of the fact that in this world of no one doing their jobs right, it’s nice to watch someone who does.

Brian Davis

I had a great experience working with Amy to sell my house! She gave a thorough overview of the sale process and had a spot-on recommendation for price that I was happy with. I received an acceptable offer IN 1 WEEK! From the beginning, I was very impressed by how knowledgeable Amy is of the housing market. It seemed to me that the sale price that Amy recommended was a bit too high as I was comparing it to the prices of homes nearby. However, Amy helped me to understand that the houses that I was comparing to were in no way comparable to my house, and she took the time to clearly explain why. I am so glad that I placed complete trust in her because, in the end, I received the full asking price for my house! Furthermore, the comparable houses in my neighborhood that were listed around the same time as my house are still on the market to date, several months after I listed my home with Amy. I definitely plan to work with Amy again when I purchase my next home!

F Senior

Amy is an exceptional professional. I first contacted her one year before my move to the Charleston area and from that first contact she proved invaluable. Her local knowledge was key to my understanding of the various areas and neighborhoods. I highly recommend her. You won't be disappointed.

Michelle Fitzgerald

We LOVED working with Amy! She took the time to understand our situation and the type of home we were looking for. She sent us links to homes before they were on the market, and was awesome in negotiations. Even after closing, she followed up to make sure we were satisfied with our purchase. She is very knowledgeable and highly recommend her services!

Jena Failla

Amy was amazing to work with and made the process of selling our home go very smoothly. She is extremely knowledgeable and ensured we made the best choices for our sale.
The photos she had taken of our house were absolutely beautiful!
She came highly recommended to us and we would highly recommend Amy to anyone looking for an agent.

Amee Chambers

I had met Amy when our girls were in elementary school together; so there was a common bond to start.
When I was ready to purchase my first home after my divorce she was the first and only person I called. I told her what I wanted and she produced. She got me in touch with a lending agent who walked me through each step. From start to finish the entire process only took about a month. Getting the financing, looking at homes, making an offer, and closing. I stayed in my place for 3 years. When I made the decision to sell, she was the only person I trusted to get the job done. It showed twice and sold in 4 days!
Amy is honest, upfront, and goes above and beyond for her clients. She is the best!

lizzyjames

Amy sold our older home in 2010, yes 2010 when the market was terrible but she got it done. She found us a great home in a neighborhood we had never even considered and got us a great price. When it came time for our son to purchase his own home, we called Amy. She was able to point us in the direction of financing and got him the perfect home. I would recommend her to anyone.

Kimberly Strong

Amy was amazing during the home search. She is knowledgeable about the market and the travel distances in the city. This purchase was part of an out-of-state corporate relocation. Exceptional customer service following the offer on the first home not working out. Excellent communication, highly responsive, honest, thoughtful, empathetic, great listener, wonderful sense of humor. She has terrific resources for assisting with after purchase needs. Would give more stars if they were available. If you are relocating from out-of-state Amy Nienstedt is the agent who will go above and beyond to make sure your home search is successful.

Professional Info

Brokerage

Carolina One Real Estate
1909 State Rd
Summerville, SC 29486

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
SC 71880
17 years experience

Awards

  • Top Producer 2023
  • Summerville’s Favorite Real Estate Agent - S'ville Journal
  • Top Producer 2022
  • Top Producer 2021

Specialties

  • Age-restricted communities
  • First-time buyers
  • Flipping & rehab
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Investment & property management
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Recreation & Vacation
  • Relocation

Designations

  • e-PRO®

Hobbies

  • Animals
  • Community Activities
  • Family
  • Food & Cooking
  • Reading
  • Volunteering

Top Cities *

Summerville

  • 27 sales past 3 years
  • 74 days on market
  • $348K median price

Moncks Corner

  • 12 sales past 3 years
  • 52 days on market
  • $360K median price

Goose Creek

  • 6 sales past 3 years
  • 50 days on market
  • $327K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.