John Caroleo

Exit Realty Achieve

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About

I'm not just here to put a sign in your yard—I'm here to get your home sold for the strongest possible price and terms.

I'm John Caroleo, a Long Island real estate salesperson, and I bring a straightforward, hands-on approach to every sale. I combine aggressive marketing, local market knowledge, strong negotiation skills, and consistent communication from our first conversation through closing.

If you're thinking about selling—even if you're just curious what your home could sell for—I’d appreciate the opportunity to earn your business.

Highlights *

1: Recent sales

$750K: Median price

3: Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Address	Sold Date	Sold Price	Represented
468 Granny Rd Medford, NY 11763	5/21/2026	$750,000	Seller

Professional Info

Brokerage

Exit Realty Achieve
956 West Jericho Turnpike
Smithtown, NY 11787

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
NY 10401381055

Specialties

First-time buyers
Foreclosures & Short sales
Relocation

Hobbies

Arts & Crafts
Cars & Automobiles
Nature
Sports

Service Areas (122 cities)

Albertson, NY Amityville, NY Asharoken, NY Babylon, NY Baldwin, NY Baldwin Harbor, NY Bay Shore, NY Baywood, NY Bellmore, NY Bethpage, NY Brentwood, NY Brightwaters, NY Brookville, NY Captree, NY Carle Place, NY Centerport, NY Central Islip, NY Centre Island, NY Cold Spring Harbor, NY Commack, NY Copiague, NY Cove Neck, NY Deer Park, NY Dix Hills, NY East Farmingdale, NY East Garden City, NY East Hills, NY East Massapequa, NY East Meadow, NY East Northport, NY East Norwich, NY East Williston, NY Eatons Neck, NY Elwood, NY Farmingdale, NY Fire Island, NY Flower Hill, NY Fort Salonga, NY Franklin Square, NY Freeport, NY Garden City, NY Garden City South, NY Gilgo, NY Glen Head, NY Glenwood Landing, NY Greenlawn, NY Halesite, NY Hauppauge, NY Hempstead, NY Herricks, NY Hicksville, NY Huntington, NY Huntington Bay, NY Huntington Station, NY Islandia, NY Islip, NY Jericho, NY Kings Park, NY Laurel Hollow, NY Levittown, NY Lindenhurst, NY Lloyd Harbor, NY Massapequa, NY Massapequa Park, NY Matinecock, NY Medford, NY Melville, NY Merrick, NY Mill Neck, NY Mineola, NY Muttontown, NY Nesconset, NY New Cassel, NY North Amityville, NY North Babylon, NY North Bay Shore, NY North Bellmore, NY North Hills, NY North Lindenhurst, NY North Massapequa, NY North Merrick, NY North Wantagh, NY Northport, NY Oak Beach, NY Oak Beach-Captree, NY Oceanside, NY Old Bethpage, NY Old Brookville, NY Old Westbury, NY Oyster Bay, NY Oyster Bay Cove, NY Plainedge, NY Plainview, NY Roosevelt, NY Roslyn, NY Roslyn Estates, NY Roslyn Harbor, NY Roslyn Heights, NY Salisbury, NY Saltaire, NY Seaford, NY Searingtown, NY Smithtown, NY South Farmingdale, NY South Hempstead, NY South Huntington, NY St. James, NY Stewart Manor, NY Syosset, NY Uniondale, NY Upper Brookville, NY Village of the Branch, NY Wantagh, NY West Babylon, NY West Bay Shore, NY West Hempstead, NY West Hills, NY West Islip, NY Westbury, NY Wheatley Heights, NY Williston Park, NY Wyandanch, NY

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.