The best way to find top real estate agents in Bay Island, Sarasota, FL

“Brandy came highly recommended to me by a trusted friend, and after working with her through the entire sale of my home, I completely understand why. She did a fantastic job from beginning to end. From getting the house ready for the market through the listing, sale, and closing, Brandy made the entire process incredibly easy and well coordinated. She stayed on top of all the details, kept me informed every step of the way, and always made sure I knew what was happening and what came next. She really took care of the moving pieces, which made selling my home much less stressful than I expected. I was also extremely impressed with how the home was marketed. The photos and listing did an excellent job highlighting the best features of the property and presenting it professionally. Now that we’ve successfully closed on the sale, I couldn’t be happier with my decision to work with Brandy. She was responsive, professional, and a pleasure to work with throughout the entire process. I’m very grateful for the original recommendation, and I would highly recommend Brandy myself to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.”

Coffey Group Fine Homes

Keller Williams Island Life

“I found Traci while searching for a buyer’s realtor. I currently live in Texas and was planning to fly to Florida to house hunt. Traci was instrumental in helping narrow down which city and neighborhood to concentrate on, knowing we were looking for a waterfront property. She showed us a combination of 21 houses and condos in 3 days, maximizing our time in Florida. She helped us realize that a house would be a better option than a condo due to exorbitant HOA fees of the listings. With her help, we discovered that we truly needed a 3/2 instead of a 2/2, and she found us the perfect one after we had already returned to Texas. Traci set us up with a mortgage rep., underwriter team, insurance company and everything that we needed for success. We were able to close in Texas via a mobile notary for our Florida retirement dream home and location. We couldn’t have done all this without her, her expertise and willingness to invest many hours of phone conversations and arrangements. Traci was tireless in her pursuit of our goal, in spite of the long distance involved. We cannot thank her enough for all of her hard work and dedication. We rate her A+++ and 10 stars!”

Traci Bolen

eXp Realty, LLC

“Scott was our advocate from start to finish in the process. Great local knowledge , patient as we navigated a new area , advised but respectful of our preferences , and just a pleasure to work with. Would recommend to anyone looking to buy in the Sarasota area.”

Jan & Scott Langa

Coldwell Banker

“He is very professional and a great negotiator. He got me a great deal on my house and was a pleasure to work with, his lender included. Highly recommend to anyone in SWFL.”

Kevin Bartlett

Knowledge Base Real Estate

“There’s not enough stars to give Kevin! Kevin is amazing! He went above and beyond to help us find our perfect home and quick! There was no time wasted! It was such a pleasure working with Kevin and we just knew we were in great hands with this whole process from very start to finish! Kevin is definitely who you want!”

David Lovitch

Keller Williams South Shore

“David is an outstanding realtor! Professional, attentive, and knowledgeable. He made the entire home buying process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!”

David & Christy Griffin

keller williams island life real estate

“First time home buyer here. From day one Michelle ensured I was taken care of. She took the time to walk me through all the processes and gave valuable input that helped me find my beautiful new home! Grateful for the time and energy she and her team put in to make the process easy and smooth. 10/10! I will be recommended all my my friends and family looking to purchase property out this way to work with Michelle.”

Michelle Olds

LPT Realty

“Austin was on top of it to help with the sale side on two of my properties and purchase of another! Highly recommended working with him.”

Austin Rios

Bellabay Realty

“Larry was an absolute gem during our home buying process. He actively sought out properties that met our needs/desires and brought them to the table ASAP. We placed multiple offers on properties and Larry guided us with his expertise of the market and leveraged practical comparisons to make the correct offers. In the end, we found our new home in under 3 weeks of working with Larry, and we couldn't be happier. We would gladly use Larry again on a future buy, and highly recommend him to others.”

Larry Lanni

eXp Realty

“Dorota was amazing. She drove an hour to help us with a rental. She showed us several different rentals. Spent hours with us and helped us with the property manager. She definitely fought for us when it came to the numbers. We would use Dorota again and again if given the opportunity. Would recommend her to anyone looking to sale, rent or purchase.”

Dorota & David

LPT Realty

“Meagan's knowledge is off the charts. Very easy to work with. Extremely friendly. Goes above and beyond what's expected. I would never use anyone else.”

Meagan Jones

Engel & Völkers Sarasota

“Laurine has a real estate knowledge second to none and was instrumental in getting our condo sold after she was successful in helping us purchase our new home. We had a limited time and she was able to get it all done. We highly recommend her services.”

Laurine Gauthier

Century 21 Rosebay

“Susan did a wonderful job making sure issues were taken care of prior to the scheduled closing she was also very involved with my lender veterans I will definitely recommend Susan to anyone who might be looking to purchase a home”

Susan Beaver

The Real Brokerage Real Broker

“Eddie did an outstanding job with navigating all parts of our closing. I have worked with a few realtors, and he is by far the best realtor I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with. At no point did I ever feel confused, rushed, or pressured into doing anything that wasn’t beneficial for my family and I. Could not recommend him enough”

Christina Griffin

Genstone Realty

“Jamie was amazing to work with! She was helpful, responsive, and made finding our new home in Florida so much easier. Since she was from our previous home state, she could easily compare the two and help us understand our options. She made the closing feel like a celebration! We’re so grateful for her and highly recommend Jamie!”

Jamie Deleon

Keller Williams KW Suncoast

“5 Stars — Exceptional Service for First-Time Homebuyers! Working with Pamela was an absolute dream, especially as a first-time homebuyer. Navigating the real estate market for the first time can feel overwhelming, but Pamela guided me through every single step of the process with immense expertise and patience. She is incredibly responsive—always available to answer questions, explain complex details, and keep things moving smoothly. What I appreciated most was how genuinely focused she was on understanding my specific needs and finding properties that matched my criteria. In the end, Pamela didn't just find a house that checked my boxes—she helped me secure a home that far exceeded all of my expectations. I couldn't have asked for a better agent or advocate. If you are looking for a dedicated, knowledgeable, and genuinely attentive realtor, I cannot recommend Pamela highly enough!”

Pamela Williams PLLC

Fine Properties

“Matt work tirelessly to negotiate everything with the sellers agent to get us a fair deal on our dream home. His fair and even keeled approach definitely took some stress out of an otherwise high pressure situation. Can’t recommend him enough!”

Matt Pereira

Blue Peak Realty

“Mayulis De La Cruz , “Quiero agradecerte por todo el apoyo que me brindaste. Tu experiencia, dedicación y profesionalismo hicieron toda la diferencia. Ha sido un placer trabajar contigo. ¡Excelente trabajo, para poder lograr este sueno que gracias a Dios es una realidad. Deseamos que Dios te siga bendiciendo en tu trabajo y en tu Vida personal. GRACIAS 😀😀😀”

Diana De La Cruz

Elevate Home Realty

“Buying our first home felt overwhelming at first, but Kim made the entire experience smooth and stress-free. From day one, she took the time to explain every step of the process in detail, making sure we always understood what to expect. She was incredibly responsive, answering all of our questions quickly and thoroughly, no matter how big or small. Kim was also flexible with scheduling, listened carefully to what we were looking for, and never made us feel rushed or pressured. She truly had our best interests at heart throughout the entire home-buying journey. She went above and beyond on closing day to make sure everything came together and that we were able to close on our first home without any issues. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor, and we highly recommend Kim to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!”

Kim Pucillo

Keller Williams Southshore

“Selling our condo was a much smoother experience than I expected, and I truly have Larry to thank for that. From the very beginning, he was knowledgeable, responsive, and incredibly professional. Night or Day, weekday or weekend Larry answered the phone and communicated actively any information about the process to us. A true professional. He guided us through every step of the process, answered all of my questions, and always made us feel confident in the decisions we were making. What impressed me most was his negotiation skills. Larry advocated for our best interests every step of the way and worked hard to secure the best possible outcome. We always felt like he had our back and never settled for less than what our home was worth. If you’re looking for an agent who is honest, strategic, communicative, and genuinely invested in their clients, we can’t recommend Larry Lazar highly enough. Selling a home can be stressful, but he made the entire process seamless. We would absolutely work with him again and recommend him to anyone buying or selling a home.”

Larry Lazar

Charles Rutenberg Realty Charles Rutenberg