Bethany currently leans toward sellers, with the market gauge firmly in seller’s market territory. Inventory is limited, with only two active listings in the latest rolling three-month period. Even with that small pool of homes, conditions have shifted noticeably compared with a year ago.
Over the most recent rolling three months ending in July 2026, the median list price sits around $247,615, which is down sharply year over year but up significantly from this spring’s $145,000 level. Active listings have roughly doubled compared with a year earlier, yet the number of new listings in this window is very small, which keeps choices tight for buyers and supports a seller-friendly environment.
Longer-term records show how variable prices can be in Bethany, with list prices over the past few years ranging from under $100,000 to above $350,000, and sale prices in recent years crossing from around $75,000 to $255,000. Days on market in past periods have also swung from just over a month to more than three months, underscoring that individual property types and price points can behave very differently in this small market. Because each listing can have an outsized impact on the numbers, local expertise matters when setting expectations. Agent Pronto can connect both buyers and sellers with an agent who understands these shifts and can help them navigate Bethany’s conditions with confidence.
