Colleen Gordon

Century 21 Scheetz

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
60 recent sales
$102K - $1.25M
e-PRO®
18 years experience
About
Colleen Gordon is an accomplished Indianapolis area agent, who brings a calculated yet personal approach to the home buying and home selling process. Colleen has built a reputation for her refreshingly friendly customer care and proven ability to guide buyers to obtain the best value for their dream home and to assist sellers to a smooth, stress free sale of their home.

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (53)

Rob and Erica
Greenwood, IN - Aug 4, 2025

Colleen Gordon is our trusted realtor every time we are in the market to buy or sell a home. Her professionalism and deep expertise make the process smooth and stress-free. She's incredibly approachable, goes the extra mile in negotiations, and handles every detail with care and dedication.

Chris Ware
Indianapolis, IN - May 26, 2024

Colleen was great to work with. There was great communication the whole time. Really worked hard to find me the right home. I didnt feel like just a number.

Abby
Indianapolis, IN - Jan 2, 2024

Colleen was absolutely amazing to work with. My boyfriend and I began our very first home buying experience with her and she made it so fun, relaxed and accessible. We were never left in the dark about any of the complicated issues that popped up during our experience and Colleen always made sure we felt comfortable and in control of our future! I would recommend her to any first time homebuyer in the area as she is such a joy to work with.

Hallie Roberts
Stilesville, IN - Jan 2, 2024

Colleen is absolutely wonderful. This is the second time we have used her and will use her again in the future. We always recommend her to friends and family. She made a stressful process, stress free. She is knowledgeable, communicative, and simply the best! We 10/10 recommend Colleen for all your real estate needs.

Michele Muller
Greenwood, IN - Dec 21, 2023

We believed that Collen knowledge of the areashorse market was excellent. Having a horse property is not easy to sell in the current market, but she not only sold it, but got our asking price and excellent closing terms on the property.

Zack and Melina
Indianapolis, IN - Mar 22, 2023

Colleen is an excellent realtor. She understood what we needed and made every effort to make it happen. She gave us time when we needed it and guidance when we asked for it. She was an amazing person to work with, always staying on top of the details and taking care of the next step for us to close on time. She is a true advocate for her clients, handling issues when they arise. For example, we had a situation where the fridge was missing from the purchased home after closing even though it was suppose to stay per the contract. She handled the liaising with with the sellers agent, negotiated a favorable solution for us, and saw it through to completion. We would love to work with her again in the future.

She should be more awesome, but she can't, because she already is THE best awesome-sauce available.

Renee Sorenson
Martinsville, IN - Feb 22, 2023

I just had the best time with Colleen! I was immediately at ease with her and felt that I was in good hands. Loved her sense of humor and personality as well as her knowledge of my target areas.

I felt like I was house shopping with my friend.

M Hutcheson
Greenwood, IN - Jan 19, 2023

We had a neighbor who used Colleen with excellent results and that played into our descision. Also after meeting her I was very impressed with her positivity and her real estate knowledge.

Really appreciate her timeliness in getting back with us and answering our questions!

This was our first transaction with Colleen and it was great! We were so thankful for a quick sale based on the current market conditions. We really appreciate everything she did to get our home sold!

This was a good experience and we are thankful to everyone involved to complete this transaction!!

As previously stated this was a great experience! We really appreciated our realtor Colleen Gordon!!! THANK YOU!!!!

Julie Albertson
Trafalgar, IN - Jan 7, 2023

Colleen has deep knowledge of the market especially as it pertains to farms.

We were thrilled with every aspect of Coleen's performance as our realtor and will continue to recommend her to others.

Colleen was always easy to reach by phone and email

TJ Vancil
Indianapolis, IN - Dec 31, 2022

Colleen is wonderful and always looking for our best interest she is very fast responding and knew exactly what we were looking for in the process I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a new home.

Nabeal
Greenwood, IN - Dec 21, 2022

Colleen was very knowledgeable and helped us purchase our first house ever.

MacKenzie Kitchel
New Whiteland, IN - Dec 20, 2022

Colleen played the biggest part in the process of buying my first home. From the very start she gave me a ton of options and we narrowed them down together, talking through all the pros and cons. Once I decided on a home she prepared me for every meeting and the closing in every way I needed to be. She made the home buying process fun, enjoyable, and something to celebrate. Colleen was out for my best interest the entire time from the moment I worked with her until even now when I have first home buyer questions. I would recommend her to anyone, she is absolutely amazing at her job and makes the process as easy and light as possibly when it is normally a stressful time.

Aaron Hamer
Indianapolis, IN - Dec 10, 2022

Colleen is a real professional, loved working with her!

Susie Patton
Greenwood, IN - Jul 15, 2022

Even though I've known Collen for years and was aware of her success in the real estate business, it wasn't until I was in the process of selling my house that I truly appreciated how devoted to her clients she is and how hard she works to achieve the best results. Colleen helped me prepare my house for sale, and when it was listed, she kept in touch with me and walked me through each step. The selling of a property is a significant life event, and Colleen went above and beyond for my sale, which I greatly appreciate.

Molly
Indianapolis, IN - Dec 30, 2021

Colleen is always friendly as can be and goes over and beyond to make all transactions as pleasant as possible!

The sell couldn’t have gone any smoother. It was fast and easy!

We have a history of selling and buying houses with Colleen and she is fantastic! Knowledgeable and thorough which is important to us! I wouldn’t use anyone else!

Jennifer
Greenwood, IN - Dec 23, 2021

Colleen did an excellent job, from beginning to end! Her knowledge of the local market was crucial and she made what can be a stressful experience much more comfortable for our family. Highly recommend Colleen and her team!

David Abell
Greenwood, IN - Dec 23, 2021

My family had used Colleen's real estate services, and they highly recommended I use her for my first home purchase. We ran into a huge sewer issue during inspections, and I was highly confident that the deal would fall through. Colleen fought back hard, and the seller gave a credit to repair not half but the whole sewer line. The home was to be sold as is, but we ended up with a large seller credit. There was never a point in the transaction that I was lost as to what was going on. As soon as Colleen had any news regarding the contract, inspection, responses, etc.. she would pick up the phone and call us right away. We were in the loop every step of the way! I will never use another realtor again. So grateful for the time and energy she put into my first home purchase. I could not have asked for a better first time home buying experience!

Thank you Colleen!

Jill P.
Greenwood, IN - Dec 23, 2021

Professional, honest, very knowledgeable and no-nonsense! She’s service oriented and one of the best agents I’ve worked with, and I was in real estate for 7 years! I am very pleased with the professionalism and service I received for a fair price from Colleen.

Jennifer Whitley
Greenwood, IN - Sep 2, 2021

Colleen made me feel like I was her only client! Her knowledge of the area and local realtors was super helpful.

Ken G
Indianapolis, IN - Sep 2, 2021

Colleen Gordon is in it to win it for you. Not difficult to trust her and enjoy the benefits.

Stephanie Riddell
Bloomington, IN - Apr 20, 2021

Colleen Gordon was great to work with.

We appreciated her patience with us as first time home buyers and her friendliness to our son who had to tag along with us sometimes.

The seller commented she enjoyed working with Colleen.

Max Clawson
Indianapolis, IN - Mar 2, 2021

Colleen Gordon was very easy and fun to work with! Her experience in the field made the process go very smoothly!

Debbie Case
Haines City, FL - Feb 22, 2021

She handled everything perfectly. Each step was perfect. Highly recommend her

Laurie Reifel
Glen Ellyn, IN - Feb 19, 2021

Colleen was very easy to work with and was a good communicator as I was out of town. Easy going and friendly style!

Eric and Beth
Greenwood, IN - Dec 29, 2020

Colleen is someone you can call and talk to and there is no pressure, she will be open and honest with you from the start. She will guide and encourage you all the way through the process until its done!

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Scheetz
1533 Olive Branch Parke Ln Suite A
Greenwood, IN 46143

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
IN RB14037192

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Luxury properties
  • Relocation

Designations

  • e-PRO®

Hobbies

  • Animals
  • Outdoor Activities
  • Shopping
  • Travel

Education

Purdue University
Bachelor’s Degree, Psychology

Top Cities *

Greenwood

  • 16 sales past 3 years
  • 55 days on market
  • $347K median price

Indianapolis

  • 15 sales past 3 years
  • 37 days on market
  • $275K median price

Whiteland

  • 3 sales past 3 years
  • 40 days on market
  • $312K median price

Service Areas (108 cities)

Amity, IN Amo, IN Anderson, IN Avon, IN Bargersville, IN Beech Grove, IN Belleville, IN Bethany, IN Bloomington, IN Blue Ridge, IN Boggstown, IN Brooklyn, IN Brown, IN Brownsburg, IN Browns Crossing, IN Carmel, IN Carrollton, IN Cartersburg, IN Centerton, IN Cicero, IN Clark, IN Clay, IN Clayton, IN Clermont, IN Columbus, IN Cordry Sweetwater Lakes, IN Crows Nest, IN Cumberland, IN Danville, IN Eden, IN Edinburgh, IN Elizaville, IN Eminence, IN Fairland, IN Fillmore, IN Finly, IN Fishers, IN Fishersburg, IN Flat Rock, IN Fortville, IN Fountaintown, IN Foxcliff Estates, IN Franklin, IN Grandview Lake, IN Greenfield, IN Greenwood, IN Guilford, IN Gwynneville, IN Helmsburg, IN Hendricks, IN Homecroft, IN Hortonville, IN Indianapolis, IN Ingalls, IN Lapel, IN Lawrence, IN Lebanon, IN London, IN Marietta, IN Martinsville, IN Maxwell, IN McCordsville, IN Meridian Hills, IN Monrovia, IN Mooresville, IN Morgantown, IN Morristown, IN Nashville, IN Needham, IN New Palestine, IN New Whiteland, IN Nineveh, IN Noblesville, IN North Crows Nest, IN Painted Hills, IN Paragon, IN Pendleton, IN Perkinsville, IN Perry, IN Philadelphia, IN Pike, IN Pittsboro, IN Plainfield, IN Pleasant View, IN Pleasant View Village, IN Prince's Lakes, IN Ripley, IN Riverwood, IN Rocky Ripple, IN Shelbyville, IN Southport, IN Speedway, IN Spring Hill, IN Spring Lake, IN Stilesville, IN Taylorsville, IN Trafalgar, IN Ulen, IN Warren Park, IN Waverly, IN Wayne, IN Westfield, IN West Newton, IN Whiteland, IN Whitestown, IN Williams Creek, IN Wynnedale, IN Zionsville, IN

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.