Find the perfect real estate agent in New Bethel, Indianapolis, IN

We analyze top real estate agents in Indianapolis’ New Bethel neighborhood and across the country to find you the most proven local agents, for free.

Equal Housing Opportunity
Real estate in Indianapolis’ New Bethel neighborhood.

The easiest way to find the best real estate agent.

Sell your home fast and for top dollar or find your dream home at the best possible price. Use our free service to find top agents you can trust.

Tell us what you need.
Answer a few quick questions about your real estate needs so we can begin our search.
Match with the perfect agent.
Our personalized matching system will connect you with a top-rated real estate agent with the local expertise and experience you need.
Meet your agent.
Review the details of your top agent recommendations and speak with them to learn exactly how they can make your real estate journey a success.
Buy and sell with confidence.
While real estate decisions are among the most important financial and personal decisions we make, you can rest easy knowing that you have a proven real estate professional on your side.
Agent profile screenshot
Agent profile screenshot

Home buyers and sellers love Agent Pronto.

Here’s what some of the 400,000+ home buyers and sellers have had to say about our service.

“Justin was most helpful dealing with an uncooperative property manager. He got the property sold quickly. I was very happy with his performance.”
5 stars
WM
William M.
Indianapolis, IN
“Josh Latham was knowledgeable, helpful, patient, kind, and very pleasant to work with. Promptly answered my questions returned emails, text and phone calls. I am planning to sell my house soon and Josh will be my go-to guy.”
5 stars
CC
Connie C.
Indianapolis, IN
“Cindy and Michael Stockhaus are, by far, the best realtors I've dealt with. Aside from their professionalism, their communication, their availability, their patience, and their overall knowledge, they are people with heart. This wasn't an easy sale, for any of us, but they maintained professionalism and absolutely seemed to care about me and what I was going through in this process of selling my dad's home. Thank you for the recommendation!”
5 stars
BM
Brenda M.
Beech Grove, IN
“Our agent was very helpful. He kept us informed every step of the way. I never thought the house would sell during the quarantine, but our agent, Barry, was able to sell our house anyway. Made things go very smooth, easy and fast. Was a great experience.”
5 stars
RB
Richard B.
South Bend, IN
“My initial contact with Mr. Gall went very well and over the next week, we looked at a number of properties within the specifications I had provided. The last morning just as I was about to go back to Vermont, he saw a home just listed by an estate. We signed a contract within a few hours.”
5 stars
CA
Craig A.
Fort Wayne, IN
“Chad was a great agent and we have referred him to others who are selling. Thank you Agent Pronto for connecting him with us.”
5 stars
DE
Deb E.
Fort Wayne, IN
“Instant match of agent and a great fit for us! Giselle was very professional and helpful in guiding us every step of the way. She's prompt with responses and incredibly patient with us with our questions, concerns, and requests. Even after the deal has closed, she still took the time to follow up with us to make sure we are properly settled in.”
5 stars
YF
Youjia F.
South Bend, IN
“The sale was stress-free and Amber really helped us get things ready.”
5 stars
NT
Nancy T.
Angola, IN
“The agent we found via Agent Pronto, Nicole Galbreath, was exactly what we needed. Nicole is professional, personable and doggedly worked our home purchase to the end. She assertively advocated for us to ensure we didn't pay too much for anything. She connected us with home inspections services that saved us money and trouble later. She answered our questions or helped us get them, however simple or complex. She even helped us engage cleaning services for after the purchase. A very positive experience!”
5 stars
BY
Bill Y.
Elkhart, IN
“Dan Nolan was great. He was very honest and up front from the beginning. We were very pleased with his expertise in real estate. He got us more money than we expected in the sale and what other realtors expected to get. The house was sold within 3 weeks from listing and we were not expecting to show it for two more weeks. Glad we did—we entered into a sales contract in week 3. Very happy with results and would definitely use Dan Nolan again.”
5 stars
LH
Laurinda H.
Tipton, IN

New Bethel real estate Market Report.

Information and statistics on the latest trends in the New Bethel real estate market, updated for June 2025. *

The typical home value in New Bethel is projected to be $302,500 for the month of May. April’s finalized data reported the typical value of a home in the neighborhood to be $300,000—down 13.04% over the previous 12 months. For comparison, city-level data pegged home values at $255,000 in Indianapolis for the most recent reporting period. That number is expected to float around $258,630 in May.

New Bethel had 16 new listings and 25 listings that went under contract in April, decreasing the area’s total available inventory to 17—down 5.56% from the previous month. Inventory is projected to have further decreased in May.

The median listing price for homes in New Bethel fell 7.22% from March to April, bringing the current median listing price to $379,950. Based on projected data for May, listing prices may continue to fall.

The number of days that homes have been on the market prior to going under contract fell year-over-year. In April 2025, the median time for a listed property to go pending was 120 days, compared to 141 days in April 2024. In recent months the median number of days from listed to pending appears to be decreasing. That trend is predicted to have carried through to this May.

Real estate in Indianapolis’ New Bethel neighborhood.
7
Seller’s Market
Seller’s Market
Buyer’s Market
0
25
50
75
100

Market gauge is calculated based on the the number of active listings divided by home sales over the most recently available reporting period.

* Data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage.

Learn more about what New Bethel has to offer.

New Bethel offers residents a vibrant community atmosphere enriched with historic charm, local amenities, and opportunities for engagement and growth.

New Bethel balances small-town ambience with easy access to the best of Indianapolis. Residents find themselves amid the friendly pace of a close-knit community, where local businesses line streets and neighbors greet one another by name. Outdoor enthusiasts take full advantage of Paul Ruster Park, a sprawling green space offering bike trails, serene picnic areas, and opportunities for birdwatching right in their backyard. The recreational options don’t stop there—nearby Southeastway Park offers 188 acres of wildlife, educational programming, and family fun, making it a beloved spot for weekend outings.

For families considering a move, educational opportunities are a definite draw. The neighborhood is served by Warren Township Schools—a district celebrated for its focus on student achievement and its supportive learning environments. New Bethel Elementary stands out as a pillar of the community, offering a nurturing space for young learners. Just a short drive brings you to dining experiences that range from classic diners to locally owned gems, such as the long-standing New Bethel Ordinary, a favorite for pizza enthusiasts.

New Bethel’s convenient location ensures a swift commute via I-74 into the heart of Indianapolis and puts residents within easy reach of surrounding areas such as Beech Grove and Franklin Township. The neighborhood’s blend of peaceful residential living, excellent schools, and proximity to both natural green spaces and city amenities makes it especially appealing for families and professionals.

Whether you are searching for your first home or considering selling, Agent Pronto connects buyers and sellers with trusted local agents who know New Bethel and its possibilities inside and out.

Woman smiling

Within a few minutes, I was paired up with an awesome agent who really knew the local area and helped me find a great condo in a super tight market. It was daunting to think about how to find the right agent. Agent Pronto got me the right agent, pronto!

Sarah W.

Take the guesswork out of finding an agent.

With over 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., it’s not easy deciding who to trust when buying or selling a home.

We’ve analyzed performance metrics, close rates, specialties, and client reviews of the top real estate agents in New Bethel to qualify the best agents for your specific needs.

We know that choosing the right real estate agent can be a stressful task. With Agent Pronto, it doesn’t have to be.

Data analysis with a human touch.

Agent Pronto works through troves of local and national housing data, client reviews, and agent performance metrics to find the top agents in Indianapolis. But we don’t stop there.

Our Agent Specialists will take into account any special requests you have when searching for your real estate agent recommendation.

Need a great agent who speaks fluent Spanish and is a luxury condo expert in your neighborhood? No problem!


Frequently Asked Questions

There are more than 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., and you want to be sure the one you partner with is an experienced and trustworthy professional with strong local expertise. Working with a proven agent will help you sell your home faster and for more money, and help you find your dream home at the best possible price.