The best way to find top real estate agents in New Buffalo, PA

We analyze thousands of real estate agents in and around New Buffalo to find you proven local professionals, for free.


  • Client Testimonials
  • Local Market Reports
  • Tailored Recommendations
  • Free Home Value Estimates
  • Agent Sales Histories
  • Free, No Obligation
New Buffalo, PA real estate

Compare top New Buffalo real estate agents.

Agent Pronto analyzes transaction data, agent specialties, and client reviews to handpick the best agents in your area. Updated for November 2026.*


*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.

The easiest way to find a top agent you can trust.

Sell faster. Buy smarter. Get matched with proven agents who know your market—all for free.

Tell us what you need.
Answer a few quick questions about your real estate goals.
Get matched.
We’ll find you top local agents based on performance, expertise, and customer reviews.
Connect and compare.
Review your personalized recommendations and choose who’s right for you.
Move forward with confidence.
Whether you’re buying, selling, or both, you’ll have a proven expert on your side.
Agent profile screenshot
Agent profile screenshot

New Buffalo real estate Market Report.

Information and statistics on the latest trends in the New Buffalo real estate market. *

Quarterly Pricing Trends for New Buffalo

Rolling three-month data ending on quarter boundaries when available.

Quarterly Pricing Trends for New Buffalo Q4 '21 Q4 '22 Q4 '23 Q4 '24 Q4 '25 Q3 '26 Median list price in Oct 2021 - Dec 2021: $180K Median list price in Apr 2022 - Jun 2022: $195K Median list price in Jul 2022 - Sep 2022: $185K Median list price in Oct 2022 - Dec 2022: $286K Median list price in Jan 2023 - Mar 2023: $246K Median list price in Jul 2023 - Sep 2023: $182K Median list price in Oct 2023 - Dec 2023: $214K Median list price in Jan 2024 - Mar 2024: $215K Median list price in Jul 2024 - Sep 2024: $288K Median list price in Jan 2025 - Mar 2025: $160K Median list price in Apr 2025 - Jun 2025: $180K Median list price in Jul 2025 - Sep 2025: $152K Median list price in Jan 2026 - Mar 2026: $249K Oct 2021 - Dec 2021 Median list price $180K Jan 2022 - Mar 2022 Median list price Unknown Apr 2022 - Jun 2022 Median list price $195K Jul 2022 - Sep 2022 Median list price $185K Oct 2022 - Dec 2022 Median list price $286K Jan 2023 - Mar 2023 Median list price $246K Apr 2023 - Jun 2023 Median list price Unknown Jul 2023 - Sep 2023 Median list price $182K Oct 2023 - Dec 2023 Median list price $214K Jan 2024 - Mar 2024 Median list price $215K Apr 2024 - Jun 2024 Median list price Unknown Jul 2024 - Sep 2024 Median list price $288K Oct 2024 - Dec 2024 Median list price Unknown Jan 2025 - Mar 2025 Median list price $160K Apr 2025 - Jun 2025 Median list price $180K Jul 2025 - Sep 2025 Median list price $152K Oct 2025 - Dec 2025 Median list price Unknown Jan 2026 - Mar 2026 Median list price $249K Apr 2026 - Jun 2026 Median list price Unknown Jul 2026 - Sep 2026 Median list price Unknown
Median list price
* Data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage.
20
Seller’s Market
Seller’s Market
Buyer’s Market
0
25
50
75
100

Market gauge is calculated using active listings and pending sales from the most recently available reporting period (Q1 2026).

Inventory in New Buffalo tends to be very limited, often with only one to three homes on the market at a time. Rolling three-month data shows just one home sold in several recent quarters, highlighting how thin the supply can be. Contract activity usually matches that low inventory, with periods where only one or two new listings and pending sales appear in a season.

Over the past few years, pricing has adjusted noticeably as buyers and sellers respond to this constrained flow of homes. The median sale price in the rolling three months ending June 2026 reached about $266,900, up sharply from roughly $142,000 at the end of 2025 and $146,500 around September 2023. Earlier periods show lower prices and more variability, such as $170,000 in early 2025 and around $195,000 at the end of 2022.

Time on market has also shifted, moving from just a few days in early 2025 to more than four months at the end of 2025, then back down to under a week by mid-2026. New Buffalo is currently characterized as a seller’s market, supported by months of supply near three in several recent periods and stretches where all closed sales went above list price. With such low inventory, changing prices, and quick decision windows in many seasons, both buyers and sellers can benefit from Agent Pronto helping them find an agent who understands these patterns.



Learn more about what New Buffalo has to offer.

New Buffalo offers residents a welcoming, tight-knit community with accessible amenities, ample outdoor recreation, and a balanced mix of small-town charm and convenient regional access.

New Buffalo draws people who want river views and small town quiet while staying within easy reach of larger hubs like Harrisburg and Carlisle. Set along the Susquehanna River, the borough has a distinctly relaxed pace, with local life oriented around outdoor recreation, community connections, and straightforward commutes via nearby Route 11/15.

Residents appreciate the access to the water and surrounding countryside. Boating and fishing on the river are popular, along with camping and hiking at Little Buffalo State Park. Families often spend weekends exploring the trails and historic features at Wildwood Park in Dauphin County, or heading to Boyd Big Tree Preserve for more rugged hiking.

Daily needs are met in nearby Newport and Marysville, while broader shopping, dining, and cultural options are an easy drive away. Families often look into schools through the Susquenita School District, and the region’s network of local businesses and services is part of what gives New Buffalo its close community feel.

Because the housing stock is relatively limited, timing and preparation are crucial for both buyers and sellers. Partnering with a knowledgeable local agent through Agent Pronto can help you understand upcoming opportunities, position your home effectively, and move quickly when the right New Buffalo property becomes available.

Find your New Buffalo real estate agent today →


Trusted by over 500,000 buyers and sellers.

See why so many people rely on Agent Pronto to make their real estate journey a success.

“Gorgeous was beyond excellent! When we had any issues with sellers she fought on our behalf! We were so happy to have someone care so much and help us find our dream home!”

Hayley Witmer ·

Photo of Keller Williams Realty
Keller Williams Realty
“I had Stephanie help me with the sale of a property and then assist my daughter in law to purchase a new property. She did an excellent job with both and was very helpful when the was problems with the sale of the home. I would recommend her for any realtor needs you may have. She is personable, efficient and has built a great support staff to assist her. All great qualities.”

Michael Conroy ·

Photo of Stephanie Holladay
Coldwell Banker Realty
“Christy got our house sold in 24 hours and was a pleasure to work with! From listing to closing, it was a very smooth process and Christy walked us through every step. She was very responsive to any questions we had and got the job done quickly and efficiently! Would definitely use Christy again.”

Nicole Myers ·

Photo of Joy Daniels
Joy Daniels Real Estate Group
“Rod was an exceptional realtor who knew exactly what we were looking for when it came to a home. While he showed us several houses over our time with him, when the right one came along, he made sure we were the first to not only see, but also helped us close the deal. He knew us well and answered every question we had along the way. Rod also made selling our house easy. His experience and professionalism made all the difference, helping us get a great result with zero hassle. We would work with Rod again in a heartbeat! Thank you Rod.”

Ann Dalby ·

Photo of Rod Martin
Iron Valley Real Estate
“We had the pleasure of working with Erika as our realtor, and we couldn't be more satisfied with the experience. From start to finish, she demonstrated exceptional professionalism, market knowledge, and genuine care for our needs. Erika was incredibly responsive to our questions and concerns, always taking the time to explain the process and keep us informed at every step. Her expertise in the local market was evident, and she provided valuable insights that helped us make confident decisions. She was patient, thorough, and never pressured us—instead, she focused on finding the right fit for our situation. What impressed us most was her dedication to getting the best outcome. She went above and beyond to negotiate favorable terms and kept the transaction moving smoothly from offer to closing. We highly recommend Erika to anyone looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, trustworthy, and genuinely invested in their clients' success. She's a true professional!”

Corey Glotfelty ·

Photo of Erika Rutt-Akens
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage
“Dawn helped in every aspect of the sale. She was very knowledgeable and answered all my questions. The few obstacles that appeared during the process were resolved in a timely manner by Dawn. Even when I offered to make calls she took care of everything. I would definitely recommend Dawn for sale and for purchase of any home.”

Ruth Torres · York Haven, PA

Photo of Dawn Graham
Coldwell Banker Realty
“Stacy was absolutely amazing to work with throughout the entire process of selling our home. From the very beginning, she was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly responsive. She guided us through every step, gave us great advice on preparing our house for the market, and made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free. Stacy’s expertise and dedication truly paid off—our home sold quickly and for a great price. She was always available to answer our questions, kept us informed, and went above and beyond to make sure everything stayed on track. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor and would highly recommend Stacy to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She genuinely cares about her clients and delivers outstanding results.”

Corey thomas ·

Photo of Stacy Trout
Coldwell Banker Realty
“We LOVED working with Amanda. She was responsive, an excellent listener, always keeping an eye out for our family, and providing helpful advice and guidance through the buying/selling process. We couldn’t recommend her enough. She is so thoughtful and kind!”

kmnolan unc ·

Photo of Amanda Scholly
Inch & Co. Real Estate, LLC
“Megan is a realtor extraordinaire! My fiancé and I recently purchased our first home, and the journey couldn't have been smoother, all thanks to her unwavering dedication and expertise. We embarked on a months-long house hunting adventure all over central PA, and Megan was there with us every step of the way. What truly sets her apart is her commitment to her clients. Megan went above and beyond by sacrificing her weekends and sometimes traveling an hour away to show us houses and answer our countless questions. Her knowledge of the local real estate market was truly impressive. Megan took the time to understand our needs and desires, and she skillfully guided us through the process of making competitive offers. Her insights and advice were invaluable in helping us secure our dream home. One standout moment in our journey was Megan's exceptional negotiation skills. She helped us negotiate mold remediation with the sellers, ensuring that our future home would be safe and healthy for our family. This was a game-changer, and we're grateful for her tenacity and advocacy on our behalf. And when our offer was accepted, the excitement was palpable. Megan's attention to detail ensured that the closing process was seamless. She kept us informed at every turn and made sure that everything was in order, making our transition into homeownership stress-free. In Megan, we not only found an exceptional realtor but also a friend who genuinely cared about our happiness and well-being. We can't thank her enough for helping us find the perfect home. If you're in the market for a realtor who combines professionalism with a personal touch and goes the extra mile to ensure your needs are met, look no further than Megan. She's a true gem in the real estate industry, and we wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home. Thank you, Megan, for making our first home-buying experience unforgettable!”

XandriaAmash ·

Photo of The Allie Rapsey Team
Coldwell Banker Realty
“Lacy went above and beyond answer any questions, concerns or requests we had during the buying and selling process! I highly recommend Lacy she isn’t afraid to dive right into working for you!”

mgjmd9psz4 ·

Photo of Lacy Grove
LUX+
“Danielle is awesome. She is extremely helpful throughout the entire process. She is very knowledgeable of the market and was able to help us buy/build a new house as well as sell our old house. I would highly recommend her, as she is very attentive with clients and has a great personality. Also, we had a much better experience with her because she is very responsive and helpful throughout the entire process. We have used other realtors in the past, but I believe that Danielle delivers the best service out of all the ones that we have used in the past. Again, I would highly recommend utilizing her to either buy or sell a home. She has a good ability to reach out to clients and understand their needs, and assist with any questions and concerns that occur throughout the process of buying or selling a home.”

Gregory Holzel ·

Photo of Danielle Wise
Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Capital Area
“We are so thankful to have worked with Jerry while we were looking for a new home. Although it took months for us to find the perfect home for our family, Jerry was always patient in our deliberations, always willing and ready to show us a house and always candid with us as we discussed pros/cons of each property. He offered his opinion when asked, but also would allow us time to process on our own. Jerry's years of experience in real estate was such an asset to us in this current real estate market. We would recommend Jerry to others and would have no hesitation to have him be our realtor again should the need ever arise!”

daisha copenhaver ·

Photo of Jerry Shilling
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage
“I had my house on market for year and it didn't sell. Mike got it sold within 24 hours of being on market. Very professional and personal care. He gave great communication and stayed on top of things.”

Marcia Jacobs ·

Photo of Mike Cotton
eXp Realty
“Amy has given my husband and I an amazing experience finding and buying our first house! She is super friendly, committed to helping people, timely with her responses and her knowledge is wonderful! I highly recommend her to anyone looking for a house or selling.”

ksstephan16 ·

Photo of Amy Moore
Kingsway Realty
“Dean is a true expert in the real estate world. He will help guide you through your purchase process to ensure a smooth experience. We had been looking for many months and across a very broad area until we found the perfect home. Thank you for all of your help.”

greg928s ·

Photo of Dean Whittaker
Exit Realty Capital Area
“Dave was very knowledgeable about how to price the house that I had for sale and helped me to adjust the price for a quick sale, He advised me on steps that I could take to make my house sell. He did very well with open houses and was able to fully explain all the benefits and features of my house.”

dyrell81 ·

Photo of Dave Heffron
Coldwell Banker Realty

Frequently Asked Questions

There are more than 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., and you want to be sure the one you partner with is an experienced and trustworthy professional with strong local expertise covering the housing market in and around New Buffalo. Working with a proven agent will help you sell your home faster and for more money, and help you find your dream home at the best possible price.


Looking for an agent outside New Buffalo?

We’ll match you with top-rated real estate agents in just about any city—wherever your next move takes you.