Sarah Flynn

Century 21 Scheetz

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
48 recent sales
$75K - $570K
8 years experience
About
Being a Quality Service Award winner for multiple years has allowed me to build numerous relationships along with repeat and referral business. I bring my sellers the highest possible dollar in the shortest amount of time. My average days on market are 10, while my list-to-sell price is 103%, compared to the market average of 100%. Sellers will appreciate my timely and straightforward communication throughout the transaction.

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (61)

Jo Ziegler
Batesville, IN - Jul 16, 2025

Sarah was familiar with the situation with my brother. She was not pushy about getting me to sell after his death. That was extremely important. She gave my family time to grieve & clean out the house. She let me contact her when we were ready. Sarah knew all along the house was going as is. She also was aware I had 3 siblings that had to agree.

I couldn't have asked for a better realtor!

Doug W.
Fishers, IN - Jul 13, 2025

Extremely happy. Got what I expected for the sale and I was kept regularly informed by Sarah and the team of what was going on. Best experience I've ever had hands down.

Kim Kuersteiner
Carmel, IN - Jul 9, 2025

THank you Sarah for everything start to finish. It was a pleasure!

Brittany Spence
Greenwood, IN - Dec 19, 2024

Sarah was absolutely wonderful to work with! I trusted her completely to assist in finding the right home for my family, and she delivered. She was always attentive, responsive, and professional!

Jackie Combs
Indianapolis, IN - Dec 19, 2024

Buying a new home is has pros and cons. Sarah and her team made this process carefree and easy to understand. Sarah was patient,informative, and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend her.

Julie Pike
Shelbyville, IN - Oct 29, 2024

I love working with Sarah. She is to the point and completely professional.

Nancy Conner
Bothell, WA - Oct 18, 2024

Sarah Flynn was knowledgeable, professional and friendly! She was a tremendous help to us through every stage of the sales process, from preparing our house for sale to the final negotiations and closing. Even though we moved out of state before the house was listed, she kept us fully informed and handled all the details exceptionally well. Highly recommended!

Matthew and Emily
Carmel, IN - Dec 2, 2023

Sarah was an incredible resource for our first time buying a home. She was easily accessible and made sure we were comfortable throughout the entire process. I would recommend Sarah to anyone who is interested in buying a home!

Ken Troutman
McCordsville, IN - Nov 9, 2023

Have worked w/Sarah Flynn for years! I had an elderly sister-in-law involved & Sarah was very understanding & patient when needing to deal w/her. Not our typical usual deal, but the typical pro & just good person she is.

Anesa
Fishers, IN - Dec 13, 2022

Sarah proactively reached out when we were trying to sell by owner. We were impressed with how professional, knowledgeable, and thorough she was. It was an easy decision for us to proceed with her as our listing agent. Would highly recommend her! She was timely with communication and ensured all our concerns with met. We felt at ease knowing she was representing us throughout the process.

Hinova
Noblesville, IN - Dec 10, 2022

Sarah is fantastic! She took what we wanted in a house seriously and helped us find the perfect house! Was always available for questions and helped lead us through this process of buying our first home

Pam Hannefey
Greenfield, IN - Aug 24, 2022

We had worked with Sarah before and enjoyed working with her and we were so glad to get to work with her again. Sarah is very committed, always quick to respond, got our questions answered, kept us updated on all deadlines and was very patient with us on our long search. We would definitely recommend her to anyone who is buying or selling.

Sarah definitely excels in all of the above professional qualities!

Jeff Smith
Zionsville, IN - Dec 8, 2021

Sarah is a true professional and and very attentive to any questions and comments.
I would recommend Sarah to any of my friends.

Sam and Charlotte
Noblesville, IN - Oct 13, 2021

Sarah Flynn brought calm steady leadership to the home sale process.

Sarah Flynn was great to work with. She was referred to us by a trusted friend and she lived up to the recommendation across the board.

The photographer and other support was excellent. The process moved quickly but also deliberately and effectively.

Well done.

Ceci Spence
Indianapolis, IN - Jul 21, 2021

Sarah exceeded our expectations during the home buying process. She provided insight into the current market, quickly translated our wishlist list to actual properties, and supported us through the entire process. We are thankful to have shared this experience with someone who prides themselves on serving others, and it shows.

Julie Pike
Greenwood, IN - Jun 24, 2021

Sarah was amazing. She is so easy to work with, professional, caring, thorough and excellent with communication. I've used her twice now and plan on using her again in 1 year when I plan to buy again. I can't recommend her enough.

Tom and Torie
Indianapolis, IN - Apr 19, 2021

Sarah was an excellent realtor for our first time buying a home. She helped us navigate a tricky market and find a great home!

Leta Donica
Indianapolis, IN - Apr 19, 2021

Sarah was very knowledgeable regarding the real estate market. With her guidance I was able to purchase a house in a very demanding housing market. Sarah is an outstanding realtor.

Say Reh
Indianapolis, IN - Mar 25, 2021

In my experience whoever I’ve ever dealt with the agent, Sarah Flynn is the most helpful person.

Nick
Indianapolis, IN - Mar 4, 2021

Sarah was great! Always will to answer any questions we had, which we had a lot being first time home buyers. She put things in terms that we could understand and helped us transition smoothly to closing day. I can’t thank her enough!

Jenny Abbott
Hartford City, IN - Jan 11, 2021

This is my third house and by far the best experience.

Fang Fang
Westfield, IN - Nov 20, 2020

We are so lucky to get to know Sarah and have her as our buyer agent, she made everything easier and faster, helped us get our dream house in Carmel. I would definately give her full score+bonus score.

Nathan Geise
Broad Ripple, IN - Oct 23, 2020

I decided to try the realtor that Realtor.com had recommended and see how things went. I was pleased with how she took my needs for a home very seriously and focused on them constantly, so I happily stayed with Sarah.
Over time I noticed she highly prioritizes getting the right home for her client, and that impressed me significantly.

Erron
Indianapolis, IN - Aug 1, 2020

Overall an excellent Realtor when purchasing and selling a property. It’s always a pleasure to work with Sarah Flynn. I’m thankful to be represented by such a knowledgeable professional.

Danielle Miller
Greenfield, IN - Jun 1, 2020

Sarah was a pleasure to work with, super understanding and helpful. Communication is key and she was always on top of texts and emails. I look forward to working with her again.

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Scheetz
270 E Carmel Dr
Carmel, IN 46032

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
IN RB15001194

Top Cities *

Indianapolis

  • 36 sales past 3 years
  • 36 days on market
  • $260K median price

Westfield

  • 2 sales past 3 years
  • days on market
  • $323K median price

Fishers

  • 2 sales past 3 years
  • 42 days on market
  • $345K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.