Tammy Tingle

Century 21 Miller Elite

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
2021: Rookie of the Year
2021: Century 21 Top Producer
2021: AINCAR Top Producer
2021: Century 21 Quality Service Award

2022: Century 21 Presidents Award
2022: Century 21 Centurion Award
2022: Century 21 Quality Service Pinnacle Award
2022: Century 21 Top 50 Realtor in Florida AGC
2022: Century 21 #1 at Miller Elite AGC
2022: Century 21 Miller Elite Greatest Year-over-Year Increase Agent

2023: Century 21 #1 at Miller Elite
2023: Century 21 Presidents Award
2023: Century 21 Miller Elite Highest Sales Volume: $23,000,000
2023: Century 21 Miller Elite Most Listings
2023: Century 21 #8 Realtor in Florida
2023: Century 21 #82 Realtor in the USA

2024: Century 21 Miller Elite #1 Realtor in Sales/Listings
2024: Century 21 #5 Realtor in Florida
2024: Century 21 #30 Realtor in the USA

2025: February Cover Realtor for Jacksonville Top Producers Magazine
2025: Century 21 Miller Elite Top Sales in January
Highlights *
45
Recent sales
$102K-$2.13M
Price range
$699K
Median price
5
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Ratings & Reviews
4.9 (127)

Gray
Fernandina Beach, FL - Jan 15, 2026

We have relocated regularly and worked with a lot of great realtors but Tammy is the best of the best.

* From the start, she gave us a realistic valuation of our property and what we should expect for the price and sales process.

* She always answered our calls immediately or if tied up, texted back quickly as to when she could return the call. Same for emails and texts.

* Tammy’s collateral materials were excellent. Especially the video tour, which was so good we briefly felt a little seller’s remorse.

* Any realtor can have lots of open houses and she did. However, Tammy’s open houses were always productive because she drove traffic to the event through her local contacts, and community focused social media. As a result, we always felt the interruption to our schedule wasn't wasted time and the eventual buyer came through the property during one of the open house events (closing price, 1.1M).

All-in-all, perfectly executed.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Chris S.
Fernandina Beach, FL - Jan 14, 2026

Tammy was very professional, knowledgeable and honest. She was easy to reach at any given time and a big help with anything and everything we needed. The purchase of our home on Amelia Island went very smoothly thanks to Tammy.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Maria Chaloux
Fernandina Beach, FL - Jan 12, 2026

Working with Tammy and Marc Tingle was a great experience from start to finish. They are truly plugged into the Amelia Island real estate market, and the results were immediate—we had a strong offer within just two days of listing. Their strategic approach, deep market knowledge, and command of pricing dynamics were fantastic. Just as importantly, Tammy and Marc are wonderful people—professional, warm, and a genuine pleasure to work with. We couldn’t recommend them more highly.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Sarah Bush
Yulee, FL - Jan 12, 2026

Tammy was absolutely outstanding to work with. From the very beginning, her professionalism, responsiveness, and deep knowledge of the local area set her apart. We were not familiar with the area, and Tammy’s insight into neighborhoods, market trends, and local nuances was invaluable in helping us make confident, informed decisions.

She guided us through every step of the process with clarity and patience, always making sure we understood our options and felt comfortable moving forward. Tammy was proactive, detail-oriented, and consistently stayed ahead of potential issues, which made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable.

What truly stood out was her dedication and genuine care. She went above and beyond to ensure everything stayed on track and that our best interests were always the priority. If you are looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, trustworthy, and deeply familiar with the area, Tammy is the one.

Verified by RealSatisfied

Penny Landregan
Fernandina Beach, FL - Dec 13, 2025

Tammy Tingle by far is the best realtor we have ever worked with in buying and selling homes. She made our sale painless and oh so smooth closing,

I will definitely spread the word that Tammy is the #1 realtor in Nassau County, Florida! Look no further!

Verified by RealSatisfied

Professional Info

Brokerage

Century 21 Miller Elite
500 Centre St
Jacksonville, FL 32234

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
FL 3493988

Awards

  • 2024 Century 21 #5 Realtor in Florida
  • 2024 Century 21 #30 Realtor in the USA
  • 2024 Century 21 Grand Centurion Award Winner
  • 2024 Century 21 Presidents Award Winner
  • 2024 Century 21 Miller Elite #1 Realtor

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Investment & property management
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Recreation & Vacation

Education

Georgia Southern University

Top Cities *

Fernandina Beach

  • 40 sales past 3 years
  • 113 days on market
  • $699K median price

Fleming Island

2 sales past 3 years

Jacksonville Beach

  • 1 sales past 3 years
  • 152 days on market
  • $1.13M median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.