Jeremy Paetsch

Watson Realty Corp.

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

About
As a lifelong resident of Amelia Island, Jeremy Paetsch offers a deep connection to the community and an unmatched wealth of knowledge about the island, Fernandina Beach, and the surrounding areas. A graduate of the University of North Florida, where he majored in Business and Economics, Jeremy entered the real estate industry in 2011 and quickly established himself as a dedicated professional. By 2013, he had obtained his Broker's License and continued to excel, becoming a perpetual Top Producing Sales Agent within Watson Realty Corp and the Nassau County Realtor Board.
Jeremy specializes in residential homes throughout Nassau County, offering expertise in everything from oceanfront homes and condos to charming, quiet properties in the peaceful western areas of the county. With a unique blend of local knowledge, a diligent work ethic, and a keen understanding of current market conditions, Jeremy is dedicated to ensuring your next real estate transaction is a smooth and successful one.
Highlights *
22
Recent sales
$155K-$1.29M
Price range
$420K
Median price
15
Years experience

Recent Listings & Sales

Ratings & Reviews
5.0 (4)

Lori Fiore
Fernandina Beach, FL - Oct 27, 2025

Jeremy has been nothing but a top notch Real Estate Agent! He not only helped us buy our condo in Fernandina Beach, Florida, he also assisted in selling it for us four years later! In between, he has been nothing but kind and professional, and always going the extra mile in showing us other properties! We look forward to using him again with our next purchase in Florida! He is the best! We highly recommend Jeremy to anyone buying or selling a home!

Source: Google

Sherrie Finn
Fernandina Beach, FL - Jul 16, 2025

We met Jeremy approx 2 years ago while shopping for a vacant lot to build our dream home, and to say he was a breath of fresh air is an understatement. I don’t think this man sleeps, ever…….

Jeremy is a top notch realtor and is a credit to the profession, tell him something once, and forget about it, just consider it done. He takes the time to know you as a person so that he can better understand your needs, and boy does he over perform.

He works harder for his clients than any other realtor we’ve met, (approx 50 sales/purchases). I know everybody things their realtor is the best, Jeremy truly is. He constantly goes above and beyond to make sure all your needs are met, he uses his local connections and contacts to ensure you are well taken care of the the transaction goes smoothly.

The biggest difference between Jeremy and other realtors is, his involvement and dedication doesn’t stop once the deals done, he stays in contact and makes sure you get setteled in.

Source: Google

Melissa Teitelbaum
Fernandina Beach, FL - Apr 24, 2025

Jeremy was on top of every step of our home buying experience. He showed us many homes, some we visited twice, until we found the one that suits our needs perfectly. Every text, email and phone call was answered within minutes. Being new to Fernandina Beach, we had a ton of questions, like HOA dues, home owners insurance, mortgage lenders, electric & water service, home inspections, pest control, screening companies, garage floor coating companies, and even waste pick up, which he provided contacts for us. All of our questions were promptly answered, in fact, he encouraged us to "bombard him with questions" -...which we did! He has a wide network of professionals available for use if we chose to use them and all were super helpful and did there job well. Everything went like clockwork. We were serious buyers, and the process from first meeting Jeremy to shaking hands at the closing table was less than 6 weeks. Jeremy is professional and personable, he listens and he delivers.

Source: Zillow

Muriel Watkins
Fernandina Beach, FL - Mar 16, 2022

Jeremy Paetsch is thoroughly competent; professional; exceptional skill in pricing our home and marketing the property - In fact we received multiple cash offers within the first two days the property was on the market. The Zillow Overview noted the following: Time on Zillow, 2 days, the listing had attracted 2,157 Views and 81 Saves. By Day 4, 3,238 Views and 106 Saves. With the guidance of Jeremy Paetsch, we were able to receive an offer beyond our expectations and close on the sale in record time.

Source: Zillow

Professional Info

Brokerage

Watson Realty Corp.
3321 South Fletcher Avenue
Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
FL BK3251815

Awards

  • AINCAR Rookie of the year 2012
  • Top Producer

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Flipping & rehab
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Luxury properties
  • Recreation & Vacation

Hobbies

  • Family
  • Music
  • Nature
  • Outdoor Activities
  • Sports
  • Travel

Education

University of North Florida
Bachelor’s Degree, Business Management/Economics
2008 - 2012

Top Cities *

Fernandina Beach

  • 15 sales past 3 years
  • 79 days on market
  • $465K median price

Yulee

  • 6 sales past 3 years
  • 166 days on market
  • $289K median price

Hilliard

  • 1 sales past 3 years
  • 109 days on market
  • $608K median price

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.