Marshall County home values have edged down over the past year, with the typical home value about 6% lower than last September. At the same time, median list prices are up roughly 5% year over year, signaling that sellers are still aiming higher even as closed prices soften. Housing supply has expanded, with months of supply up more than 70% compared with last year, easing some of the pressure on buyers.
In the latest September 2026 snapshot, the typical home value sits around $225,000, while the median list price is near $293,000. Homes are taking longer to sell than a year ago, with the median days on market at 46 days and up about 8% annually, and inventory has grown to 165 active listings, slightly above last year’s level.
Recent sales activity shows some slowing, as only 36 homes sold in September, down from both the prior month and last year, and pending sales are down nearly 40% year over year. Even so, about 29% of homes are selling above list price, and sellers are still achieving an average of roughly 98% of their asking price, suggesting that well-priced homes can perform strongly. Compared with Indiana overall, Marshall County has lower typical home values but more supply at 3.8 months versus the state’s 2.9 months, giving buyers relatively more options while still rewarding prepared sellers, and Agent Pronto can help both buyers and sellers find an agent who understands these conditions.
