Asbury Lake is seeing a steady flow of homes coming to market, with 74 new listings and a total inventory of 210 properties in March 2026. Contract activity is solid as 91 homes went pending, and with about 5 months of supply, conditions lean toward a seller’s market even as options for buyers are still present.
Pricing is edging upward, with the typical home value at about $367,000 and the median list price around $374,235. Compared with last year, typical values are up 2.29 percent and contract prices are close to asking, with homes selling for about 98.8 percent of list on average.
Time on market has been shifting, with the typical listing spending 113 days before going under contract, down roughly 33 percent from a year ago but up nearly 19 percent from last month. Around 30 percent of sellers have reduced their price, and only about 11.9 percent of homes sold above list, showing buyers have some negotiating power even in a seller-leaning environment. Compared with Clay County overall, Asbury Lake’s typical value of $367,000 sits a bit above the county’s $355,000, and values in both areas are projected to rise modestly into April. Whether buyers want to navigate price trends or sellers hope to capitalize on strong demand, Agent Pronto can connect them with a local agent who understands this market.
