- Agent Pronto
- New Jersey
- Spring Lake Heights
- Katie Reynolds
Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?
I crave a challenge and will rise to meet it every time. You can count on me to go above and beyond and to leverage my contacts, creativity, and unwavering work ethic to ensure that your goals are achieved within the time frame you desire.
I’m the professional that others love to work with, and believe me—that matters!
- 46
- Recent sales
- $215K - $3.38M
- Price range
- $697K
- Median price
- 21
- Years experience
Recent Listings & Sales
| Address | Sold Date | Sold Price | Represented |
|---|---|---|---|
|
109 Evergreen Ave #109
Neptune City, NJ 07753
|
8/17/2026 | $510,000 | Buyer |
|
813 Ocean Rd #813
Spring Lake Heights, NJ 07762
|
8/11/2026 | $1,050,000 | Seller |
|
81 Salem Rd #81
Brick, NJ 08724
|
7/31/2026 | $740,000 | Buyer |
|
447 Woodmere Ave #447
Neptune Township, NJ 07753
|
7/30/2026 | $675,000 | Seller |
|
2005 Nassau Dr
Spring Lake, NJ 07762
|
7/29/2026 | $840,000 | Seller |
Transaction History *
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 10
- Total Value
- $12,357,405
- Median Sale Price
- $863,500
- Price Range
- $525K - $3.38M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 8
- Total Value
- $4,770,000
- Median Sale Price
- $602,500
- Price Range
- $255K - $851K
Sales Volume Timeline
Lighter, dashed segments indicate partial quarters. Totals include only dates within the displayed period.
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 14
- Total Value
- $15,652,405
- Median Sale Price
- $863,500
- Price Range
- $525K - $3.38M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 16
- Total Value
- $12,154,000
- Median Sale Price
- $667,000
- Price Range
- $215K - $1.5M
Sales Volume Timeline
Lighter, dashed segments indicate partial quarters. Totals include only dates within the displayed period.
Seller Deals
- Total Deals
- 25
- Total Value
- $22,673,405
- Median Sale Price
- $752,000
- Price Range
- $215K - $3.38M
Buyer Deals
- Total Deals
- 21
- Total Value
- $15,578,000
- Median Sale Price
- $615,000
- Price Range
- $215K - $1.5M
Sales Volume Timeline
Lighter, dashed segments indicate partial quarters. Totals include only dates within the displayed period.
Ratings & Reviews
5.0
(24)
We can’t thank Katie enough for helping us find our first home! Not only is Katie the most kind and genuine person, but her knowledge and expertise in the field is truly unmatched - especially for first-time homebuyers like us who learned so much throughout the process. We knew that with Katie’s professionalism, efficiency and incredible communication skills, we would find the exact home we were looking for. We are so grateful for Katie and her hard work and effort towards helping us. We couldn’t be happier in our new home!
Source: Zillow
Katie Reynolds is the best out there. Her dedication and passion for her clients is outstanding. When we were ready to list our home,I told my husband I want Katie to sell it no one else. My neighbor next door had her house up for sale a few years ago and she went through 3 realtors before she found Katie and Katie was the one that sold her house. Katie goes above and beyond. She had a brokers open house just for Relators that deal with waterfront properties. She put our house on utube with the drone she had showing different angles of the house. She got us more money than we were asking. She is such a pleasure to work with. We will miss her. Besides being the best realtor she is such an amazing caring person. Trust her with your home you won’t be disappointed. Thanks from the bottom of our hearts Katie. We’ll miss you.
Source: Zillow
We had the pleasure of working with Katie Reynolds to find our first home. Katie took us on several walk throughs and thoughtfully gathered our ideas to recommend the right properties for us. Choosing a boutique firm like Salt and Cedar worked for us because we had a personalized experience from start to finish. Since this was our first time buying a home, we used all of Katie’s recommendations for title company, mortgage lender, inspector, and attorney. These are working relationships she has built over the years and we believe we had the best team surrounding us.
When we found “the one,” Katie acted swiftly to help us prepare a competitive offer that won us the house. In this crazy market, we couldn’t believe how lucky we got.
After the inspection process, we faced some challenges, but Katie handled them with grace and confidence. We felt assured that everything would go smoothly. Katie was determined to help us close on time, and she successfully realized that.
We would recommend Katie Reynolds and Salt and Cedar Properties to anyone in the community who wants a kind, gracious, but strong agent by their side. We recommend S&C highly!
Source: Zillow
Katie did a really good job taking the time to learn about our unique situation, noting my wife and I have very different styles and needs. She showed us a wide array of properties to help us figure out our "ideal" home. Once we had identified properties, Katie was really good at establishing the right amount to offer (or not which is also very valuable); and then working with the seller to close out on what was a tricky deal, with a delayed closing. Her creativity throughout the buying process was excellent. I would recommend Katie to anyone seeking a new home near the shore. Very personable, engaging, and knowledgeable.
Source: Zillow
As a first time home buyer, Katie guided and taught me the process. She made it stress-free and helped every step of the way. Absolutely would recommed to anyone!
Source: Zillow
Professional Info
Brokerage
309 Morris Ave
Spring Lake, NJ 07762
Licensed
NJ 0679991
Specialties
- First-time buyers
- Luxury properties
- Recreation & Vacation
Designations
- ABR®
- SRS
Top Cities *
Spring Lake Heights
- 6 sales past 3 years
- 69 days on market
- $775K median price
Brick
- 6 sales past 3 years
- 48 days on market
- $525K median price
Toms River
- 5 sales past 3 years
- 41 days on market
- $415K median price
Service Areas (30 cities)
*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.