We analyze thousands of real estate agents in Old Tappan and nationwide to find you proven local professionals, for free.
Agent Pronto analyzes transaction data, agent specialties, and client reviews to handpick the best agents in your area. Updated for November 2026.*
*Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.
Sell faster. Buy smarter. Get matched with proven agents who know your market—all for free.
Information and statistics on the latest trends in the Old Tappan real estate market. *
Jul 1, 2026 - Sep 30, 2026
Rolling three-month data ending on quarter boundaries when available.
Rolling three-month data ending on quarter boundaries when available.
Rolling three-month data ending on quarter boundaries when available.
Rolling three-month supply and activity totals for the selected period.
Rolling three-month supply and activity totals for the selected period.
Rolling three-month supply and activity totals for the selected period.
Market gauge is calculated using active listings and pending sales from the most recently available reporting period (Jul 2026 - Sep 2026).
Old Tappan’s rolling three-month snapshot shows moderate inventory with 43 active listings and 17 new listings, both slightly higher than a year ago. Homes are still moving, with 14 sales and 20 properties going under contract, reflecting a modest year-over-year increase in closed and pending deals. Months of supply has climbed to 5, up sharply from a year earlier, signaling more options for buyers even as the market gauge still classifies conditions as a seller’s market.
Pricing has adjusted from last year’s peak but remains elevated overall. The typical home value over the latest three-month period is down about 7 percent year over year, while the median list price is up roughly 7 percent from a year ago, suggesting sellers are still aiming high even as closed values soften. At the same time, the average sale-to-list ratio has edged above 101 percent and the share of homes selling above asking, though down from last year, still sits near 29 percent, indicating buyers continue to pay close to or slightly above list for desirable properties.
Days on market offer another sign of shifting dynamics, now at 82 days and slightly faster than a year ago, even though they have lengthened compared with early summer. Roughly 45 percent of homes go off the market within two weeks, so well-priced listings can still attract quick interest. With these mixed signals of increased supply, firm pricing, and selective urgency, both buyers and sellers in Old Tappan can benefit from an Agent Pronto–recommended real estate agent to navigate strategy and timing.
Old Tappan offers residents a peaceful, close-knit community with strong schools, convenient access to major commuting routes, abundant green space for outdoor recreation, and a safe, scenic environment that supports a high quality of life.
Old Tappan immediately stands out from nearby options like River Vale and Northvale for its rare blend of small-town scale, strong schools, and abundant green space wrapped around the Lake Tappan reservoir. The community feels close knit, yet residents enjoy convenient access to Harrington Park, Norwood, and commuting routes into New York City.
Life here tends to revolve around local institutions and recreation. Families are drawn to Old Tappan’s public schools, including Charles DeWolf Middle School and Northern Valley Regional High School at Old Tappan, both known for academics and extracurriculars. Outdoor time is a priority, with facilities such as Oak Tree Elementary’s surrounding fields and neighborhood parks plus easy access to regional open space via the nearby Rockleigh Nature Preserve. Residents enjoy seasonal events and sports at Old Tappan Borough’s recreation programs, which help newcomers feel at home quickly.
Everyday conveniences include local favorites like coffee spots and delis, along with larger shopping options in neighboring Paramus and Closter. Housing ranges from long-held family homes on tree-lined streets to updated properties that appeal to move-up buyers and downsizers.
In a competitive, low-inventory market, timing and preparation are essential. Whether you are considering a first purchase in Old Tappan or planning to list a longtime residence, Agent Pronto connects you with an agent who understands local dynamics so you can move confidently and at the right moment.
See why so many people rely on Agent Pronto to make their real estate journey a success.
“Daniel is highly professional and has a team that always responds in a timely manner and is very efficient. The property I had was out of state, Daniel took care of everything that needed to be taken care of and saved me loads of trouble. He monitored the entire process and made sure everything was handled with utmost professionalism. Daniel is definitely the best and I cannot thank him enough for taking care of this for me.”
“I want to take a moment to express my heartfelt appreciation for my real estate agent, Emily. Buying a house is not an easy journey, and my journey to owning home came with so many challenges, unexpected obstacles, and moments when I felt like giving up. But through it all, Emily never stopped fighting for me. She stood by my side, pushed when things got difficult, and continued to advocate for me when I needed someone in my corner. Emily, you didn’t just help me find a house; you helped me fight for a dream. You saw how much this meant to me, and you gave me encouragement and support when I needed it most. Your dedication, patience, and determination mean more to me than words can explain. I know this journey wasn’t easy, but I’m truly grateful that I had you by my side. Not every real estate agent goes above and beyond the way you did, and I will never forget the effort you put into helping me get to this point. Thank you, Emily, for fighting for me, believing in my dream, and helping me get closer to turning a house into a home. You will always be a special part of my homeownership journey. May God bless you for the heart you put into your work and for the difference you make in people’s lives.”
“Vesna was wonderful. She did an amazing job. She is a world class professional. No excuses just results. Long story short God bless me with her. She is simply a legend. Hands-down the best. My words could express how instrumental she was in selling my property. Thank you Vesna!”
“Maureen and Bill did an amazing job selling our home. They were knowledgeable, quick to respond, and most importantly, they were patient. Thank you both for all you did! It was greatly appreciated.”
“Heather recently helped me complete a home purchase and she was truly amazing from start to finish! I came to her after not having much success previously. I had seen 20+ homes before and could not get anywhere. I saw one home with her and she managed to get the deal closed within a month! She is extremely responsive and will go the extra mile every time for her clients! I felt that she had my best interest in mind and was very knowledgeable throughout the entire process. She takes her time with every interaction and every negotiation and truly wants to see you succeed in this journey. She is there for you every step of the way and I could not be more thankful for her endless support throughout this journey. She is so kind, thoughtful, and just an altogether amazing person filled with so much joy and excitement. It is clear to see she loves what she does. If you are in the home buying journey and have been struggling or want to find a home especially in this current market, I highly recommend reaching out to Heather. She will get it done no matter the circumstance! The best part is she doesn’t disappear right after the closing like other realtors. She is there for you even after to help you get adjusted to your new home and be a resource for you as you embark upon this new journey. That itself is rare and just proves her dedication and commitment to providing superior service and instilling trust to her clients! Truly exceptional realtor and so thankful we crossed paths!”
“This is the only agent you will ever want to work with . I’ve been renting since 2009 . I’ve seen the horrors . This agent really ,truly cares. She goes above and beyond for you . She checks in to make sure everything is going good and makes sure you are taken care of . I can’t say enough amazing things about Edel I never will ever work with another real estate agent . I have recommended her to all coworkers family and friends. She is an amazing human being as well as an incredible realtor.”
“Words truly feel insufficient to describe the impact Cory has had on my experience—not only as my realtor, but as someone I now consider a friend. Selling a home and purchasing a new one can be an incredibly emotional and stressful process, and Cory guided me through every step with an extraordinary amount of patience, kindness, professionalism, and genuine care. Somehow, he was able to understand what I needed even during the moments when I could not quite articulate it myself. His knowledge, instincts, and seemingly endless network of resources made me feel supported and reassured from beginning to end. What stood out most to me, however, was Cory’s patience during my moments of significant anxiety. He never made me feel rushed, difficult, or like I was asking too much. He simply remained steady, responsive, and reassuring. Somewhere along the way, he went from being my realtor to becoming my friend. Cory’s dedication to his clients and his passion for what he does are unmistakable. His commitment did not end when the papers were signed—he continued to check in and help me well after my closing, which speaks volumes about the kind of person and professional he is. If you are selling your home or searching for a new one and want someone who will genuinely advocate for you, listen to you, guide you, and make an inherently stressful process feel manageable, Cory is the person you want beside you. I would recommend him a million times over to everyone I love and care about. There is simply no one else I would trust with something this important, and he is the only realtor I will ever use again. Cory, thank you for helping me close one chapter of my life and begin another. I will always be grateful for the role you played in getting me home.”
“My experience with Raphaela was amazing . She was very helpful communicative and knowledgeable, when it came to finding my apartment. I highly recommend her to help you find your home.”
“Jessenia is amazing as a realtor, a lender and a person! Very kind, empathetic, responsive, always keeping me up to date in the entire process and explaining anything I needed. We had a few bumps along the way in the process, but these things that are out of our control happen, and she still made sure we made it to closing and that everything was taken care of. Thank you soooo much Jessenia!”
“Pete and Ashley were a phenomenal team that made selling our house seamless even though we were several states away through the entire process! Pete even repainted a wall after the movers dented it when they were clearing the house. Whose agent does that? Ours! Or yours, if you go with Pete and Ashley. Truly honored and humbled to have had them holding our hand every step of the way.”
“Words are not enough to describe how pleased I have been with using Jennifer as my realtor. She is kind, efficient, and extremely helpful with the home-buying experience. If I had any question or concerns, Jennifer had thorough answers promptly. She is a true professional who knows the homebuying process inside and out! I am now lucky enough to live in a wonderful home in a great town. I know this would not have been possible without Jennifer's expertise and experience. I would highly recommend her to anyone considering buying a home. She is amazing!”
“I had a great experience working with the Feagles Home Team to find a tenant for my rental property. They were knowledgeable, responsive, and handled the entire process professionally from start to finish. They helped market the property, screened qualified applicants, and found a tenant quickly, making the experience smooth and stress-free. I appreciated their communication and attention to detail throughout the process. I would gladly recommend them to anyone looking for help with a rental property.”
“Woojin helped my husband and I buy our first home and it could not have been a better experience. He was so knowledge and willing to take us wherever we asked. He vouched for our sale and ultimately got us a great deal. We could not be more happy”
“THE BEST.. Completed 3 deals with Chris in the last 4 years..I wouldn't even consider working with anyone else. He's always available, and helps guide you through the whole process. A true professional”
“Vanessa is an outstanding sales professional and made the journey of selling our family home in Wyckoff such a great experience. Her market expertise and competitive sales and pricing strategy was instrumental in delivering results that exceeded our expectations. Vanessa coached us every step of the way and with her creative eye and impeccable taste, gave us valuable recommendations to prepare our home for sale without the need for staging. Vanessa has terrific communication skills. Her knowledge of the process, poise and sales confidence and connections with local contractors gave us the assurance take a 5 week vacation once the house was listed. Her attention to every detail allowed us to stay on course for the closing and she was by our side for home inspections, closing permits etc. Vanessa is friendly, witty and a positive person who generally cares for her clients and is always two steps ahead making the sellers experience a remarkable experience.”
“We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor (buyer’s agent). From the initial consultation to closing, Ingrid was attentive, organized, and extremely knowledgeable about the local market. She helped us submit competitive offers, coordinated inspections, and kept everything on track. She had available home inspectors; contractors, you name it...she had a contact! Communication was excellent, and we always felt informed. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trusted knowledgeable real estate professional.”
“Alisa is the MOST incredible, top real estate agent who made selling our home in River Vale (Bergen County, NJ) easy! She sold our mom’s home previously and we did not hesitate to seek her services once again. Alisa literally came over, sat us down, showed us comps, discussed pricing the house right and what we needed to do to prepare for an open house. Our house was sold within 24 hours after going on the market. She recognized serious buyers, didn’t play games, worked seamlessly with our attorney and was present during any inspections, walk throughs, and basically had a whole team of skilled people behind her who made the house ready to close. Aside from packing, we literally did nothing but sign paperwork! Wow! Forever grateful and thankful!”
“Sibia was very professional, punctual, honest and hard working. She was very transparent with us and was always willing to go the extra mile for us. We found her to be responsible, friendly and always there for us. I would recommend her as I am confident she will put in her best efforts for any client she works with. She was able to communicate with us very clearly and effectively, and made the whole process of buying the property very easy,”
“Kush has been our realtor when buying and selling our home. Kushtrim is 'THE' most amazing realtor you could ever ask for. This man is one in a million find. He will go far above and beyond what any other realtor would ever do for a client. He makes sure the home you get is everything you could ever want and more. He won't give up until you have your exact dream home. He's been the #1 realtor because of his passion and dedication to his clients and it show's. He is everything a realtor should be and more. Kush has not only been our realtor, but he's become family to us. If youre looking for someone to always have your best interest at heart and always be there for you anytime with anything, Kush is your man.”
“Annie did outstanding job during my home buying process. She demonstrated a high level of professionalism, responsiveness and thoughtfulness. She was consistently responsive and proactive, keeping us informed at every step and providing clear guidance on each part of the process - from identifying suitable properties, navigating offers and inspections, to post closing. She was supportive, patient and always available answer questions and offer thoughtful insights on each property I visited. I'm grateful for the enjoyable experience working with Annie and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home.”
There are more than 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., and you want to be sure the one you partner with is an experienced and trustworthy professional with strong local expertise covering the housing market in and around Old Tappan. Working with a proven agent will help you sell your home faster and for more money, and help you find your dream home at the best possible price.
Choosing a real estate agent to help you buy or sell property is one of the most important decisions you’ll make in your lifetime. You want to make sure your agent is an expert in your area, has a proven record helping people buy and sell similar homes to yours, and is well regarded by their previous clients. Let us know a few details about the property you are selling or the kind of home you want to buy, and Agent Pronto will match you with trusted real estate agents that have the experience you need. And before you interview an agent, check out our top five questions to ask a buyer’s agent and listing agent.
We consider performance metrics, close rates, specialties, and client reviews to qualify the best full-time agents. We then take the information you provide about the home you are selling or the kind of home you want to buy, and analyze the top local agents with the right experience for your specific needs. For more than a decade, we've helped hundreds of thousands of home buyers and sellers find the right agent. Get started now and find the perfect real estate agent.
No. Agent Pronto is a free service for home buyers and sellers and you are under no obligation to work with our recommended agents. Find your Old Tappan Realtor® or real estate agent today.
We’ll match you with top-rated real estate agents in just about any city—wherever your next move takes you.