1. Agent Pronto
  2. New Jersey
  3. Mystic Island

The best way to find top real estate agents in Mystic Island, NJ

We analyze thousands of real estate agents in Mystic Island and nationwide to find you proven local professionals, for free.

Mystic Island, NJ real estate

Compare top Mystic Island real estate agents.

Agent Pronto analyzes transaction data, agent specialties, and client reviews to handpick the best agents in your area. Updated for June 2026. *


* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.

The easiest way to find a top agent you can trust.

Sell faster. Buy smarter. Get matched with proven agents who know your market—all for free.

Tell us what you need.
Answer a few quick questions about your real estate goals.
Get matched.
We’ll find you top local agents based on performance, expertise, and customer reviews.
Connect and compare.
Review your personalized recommendations and choose who’s right for you.
Move forward with confidence.
Whether you’re buying, selling, or both, you’ll have a proven expert on your side.
Agent profile screenshot
Agent profile screenshot

Mystic Island real estate Market Report.

Information and statistics on the latest trends in the Mystic Island real estate market. *

Latest Rolling 3-Month Snapshot

Mar 1, 2026 - May 31, 2026

Median sale price
$408K
+8.9% from Q1 '26
Median list price
$446K
+6.2% from Q1 '26
Active listings
133
+30% from Q1 '26
Homes sold
58
+29% from Q1 '26
New pendings
70
+40% from Q1 '26
New listings
93
+50% from Q1 '26

Quarterly Pricing Trends for Mystic Island

Rolling three-month data ending on quarter boundaries when available.

Quarterly Pricing Trends for Mystic Island Q2 '21 Q2 '22 Q2 '23 Q2 '24 Q2 '25 Q1 '26 Median sale price in Apr 2021 - Jun 2021: $269K Median sale price in Jul 2021 - Sep 2021: $285K Median sale price in Oct 2021 - Dec 2021: $310K Median sale price in Jan 2022 - Mar 2022: $320K Median sale price in Apr 2022 - Jun 2022: $350K Median sale price in Jul 2022 - Sep 2022: $345K Median sale price in Oct 2022 - Dec 2022: $305K Median sale price in Jan 2023 - Mar 2023: $320K Median sale price in Apr 2023 - Jun 2023: $334K Median sale price in Jul 2023 - Sep 2023: $363K Median sale price in Oct 2023 - Dec 2023: $413K Median sale price in Jan 2024 - Mar 2024: $404K Median sale price in Apr 2024 - Jun 2024: $400K Median sale price in Jul 2024 - Sep 2024: $385K Median sale price in Oct 2024 - Dec 2024: $390K Median sale price in Jan 2025 - Mar 2025: $363K Median sale price in Apr 2025 - Jun 2025: $400K Median sale price in Jul 2025 - Sep 2025: $397K Median sale price in Oct 2025 - Dec 2025: $415K Median sale price in Jan 2026 - Mar 2026: $375K Median list price in Apr 2021 - Jun 2021: $300K Median list price in Jul 2021 - Sep 2021: $340K Median list price in Oct 2021 - Dec 2021: $331K Median list price in Jan 2022 - Mar 2022: $349K Median list price in Apr 2022 - Jun 2022: $350K Median list price in Jul 2022 - Sep 2022: $345K Median list price in Oct 2022 - Dec 2022: $299K Median list price in Jan 2023 - Mar 2023: $350K Median list price in Apr 2023 - Jun 2023: $359K Median list price in Jul 2023 - Sep 2023: $385K Median list price in Oct 2023 - Dec 2023: $369K Median list price in Jan 2024 - Mar 2024: $415K Median list price in Apr 2024 - Jun 2024: $422K Median list price in Jul 2024 - Sep 2024: $389K Median list price in Oct 2024 - Dec 2024: $435K Median list price in Jan 2025 - Mar 2025: $415K Median list price in Apr 2025 - Jun 2025: $400K Median list price in Jul 2025 - Sep 2025: $375K Median list price in Oct 2025 - Dec 2025: $440K Median list price in Jan 2026 - Mar 2026: $420K Apr 2021 - Jun 2021 Median sale price $269K Median list price $300K Jul 2021 - Sep 2021 Median sale price $285K Median list price $340K Oct 2021 - Dec 2021 Median sale price $310K Median list price $331K Jan 2022 - Mar 2022 Median sale price $320K Median list price $349K Apr 2022 - Jun 2022 Median sale price $350K Median list price $350K Jul 2022 - Sep 2022 Median sale price $345K Median list price $345K Oct 2022 - Dec 2022 Median sale price $305K Median list price $299K Jan 2023 - Mar 2023 Median sale price $320K Median list price $350K Apr 2023 - Jun 2023 Median sale price $334K Median list price $359K Jul 2023 - Sep 2023 Median sale price $363K Median list price $385K Oct 2023 - Dec 2023 Median sale price $413K Median list price $369K Jan 2024 - Mar 2024 Median sale price $404K Median list price $415K Apr 2024 - Jun 2024 Median sale price $400K Median list price $422K Jul 2024 - Sep 2024 Median sale price $385K Median list price $389K Oct 2024 - Dec 2024 Median sale price $390K Median list price $435K Jan 2025 - Mar 2025 Median sale price $363K Median list price $415K Apr 2025 - Jun 2025 Median sale price $400K Median list price $400K Jul 2025 - Sep 2025 Median sale price $397K Median list price $375K Oct 2025 - Dec 2025 Median sale price $415K Median list price $440K Jan 2026 - Mar 2026 Median sale price $375K Median list price $420K
Median sale price
Median list price
* Data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage.
19
Seller’s Market
Seller’s Market
Buyer’s Market
0
25
50
75
100

Market gauge is calculated using active listings and pending sales from the most recently available reporting period (Mar 2026 - May 2026).

Year-over-year, Mystic Island home values have inched up, with the typical home value rising about 2% to roughly $408,000 in this rolling three-month view. Listing prices show a similar pattern, up a bit more than 1% from a year ago, while homes sold and active listings have both dipped slightly, suggesting somewhat tighter inventory than last year.

Looking specifically at the latest rolling three months through May 2026, the median list price is about $446,000 and there are 133 active listings. Months of supply sits at 3.3, reinforcing the current seller’s market reading, and the typical home is spending around 37 days on the market.

Momentum has picked up recently, as new listings have grown just over 1% year over year while pending sales are up about 4%. Only about 21% of recent sales closed above list price and the average sale-to-list ratio is just under 100%, so negotiation still plays an important role for both sides of the table. Buyers and sellers who want to navigate these shifting numbers in Mystic Island can turn to Agent Pronto to connect with a local real estate agent who understands this market from both perspectives.



Learn more about what Mystic Island has to offer.

Mystic Island offers residents a tight-knit, coastal community with easy access to beaches, parks, boating, and essential amenities that support an active, balanced lifestyle.

Mystic Island is a waterfront community in southern Ocean County, offering lagoon-front living with practical access to nearby employment and recreation. Located near Little Egg Harbor, it sits within reach of larger hubs like Toms River and Atlantic City while maintaining a quieter residential feel.

Everyday needs are close at hand, with local shopping, marinas, and casual dining throughout the area. Families appreciate access to the Little Egg Harbor School District and the regional Pinelands Regional High School, along with nearby programs at Ocean County College. Outdoor enthusiasts are drawn to fishing and boating on the extensive canal system, along with quick access to open water. Nature is a constant presence, from the coastal landscapes of Edwin B. Forsythe National Wildlife Refuge to the trails in Bass River State Forest.

Weekend escapes are easy, with the beaches of Long Beach Island and family attractions in Stafford Township a short drive away. Local dining and seasonal events in nearby Barnegat Township add to the sense of a connected coastal community.

Whether you are weighing flood zones, bulkhead condition, or commute routes, a local agent who understands Mystic Island’s unique waterfront layout can simplify choices and reduce stress. Agent Pronto connects both buyers and sellers with professionals who know this market in detail and can guide each step with confidence.

Find your Mystic Island real estate agent today →


Trusted by over 500,000 buyers and sellers.

See why so many people rely on Agent Pronto to make their real estate journey a success.

“I would recommend Lisa in a heartbeat. She listened and truly had my wants and needs as a top priority. She also made sure I didn't end up homeless or in an uncomfortable situation.”

Suzanne Wicker · Manchester, NJ

Photo of Lisa Ball
Century 21 Solid Gold Realty
“Camille was amazing in helping us find our forever home!”

Jared Delorenzo · Forked River, NJ

Photo of Camille Simms
RE/MAX At Barnegat Bay
“I have used other agents in the past. Since I have worked with Maureen Yetman over the last few years her knowledge and professionalism is second to none. We will definitely retain her services for any properties in the future.”

Jo Anna · Belford, NJ

Photo of Maureen Yetman
Century 21 Thomson & Co.
“Thomas made the process so streamlined, simple and enjoyable. His communication was top-notch as far as providing us with updates, any documents, etc. He handled everything in an incredibly timely manner and made the entire experience completely stress-free and we couldn't recommend him more! He displayed the upmost professionalism and was a pleasure to work with!”

Sara · Ocean Gate, NJ

Photo of Aleksandra Rodrigues
Keller Williams Atlantic Shore
“Dan was a great agent to work with. Helped us work through some issues with the property and insured that we were satisfied with the location prior to us signing the lease. Would strongly recommend Dan to anyone looking for a property in Ocean County.”

Ed · Forked River, NJ

Photo of Dan Simms
RE/MAX At Barnegat Bay
“Eugene is great to work with. Very responsive and helpful. We would recommend in the future.”

Leah LaManna · Forked River, NJ

Photo of Team Bator
RE/MAX at Barnegat Bay
“Susan was incredibly helpful throughout the entire home selling process. Her knowledge and experience in real estate made everything feel smooth and stress-free from start to finish. She was always available to answer questions, explain every step, and make sure everything stayed on track. I truly appreciated her professionalism, communication, and dedication. I highly recommend Susan to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares and knows the business inside and out!”

Kyle · Bayville, NJ

Photo of Susan  Lucas Sterling
RE/MAX at Barnegat Bay
“Selling my condo felt overwhelming at first, but working with Tina Torres made the entire process smooth and successful from start to finish. Her professionalism, knowledge, communication and dedication were truly outstanding. Tina was always available to answer questions, kept me informed every step of the way and worked incredibly hard to make sure everything stayed on track. Thanks to her expertise, my condo sold quickly and the Closing process went smoothly. What stood out the most was how much Tina genuinely cared about me as a client, not just about making a sale. I always felt supported, respected and confident that I was in the best hands possible. I couldn't have asked for a better experience and would highly recommend Tina Torres to anyone buying or selling a home. She is truly one of the best realtors out there!!”

Michelle Cruz · Elizabeth, NJ

Photo of Tina  Torres
RE/MAX Lifetime Realtors
“Chris was incredible and helped me find my first home. He was very knowledgeable and communicated everything clearly, and I would highly recommend him to my friends and family.”

Vanessa · Morganville, NJ

Photo of Christopher Quinn
Century 21 Action Plus Realty
“Mary Ann understood what I wanted and found just the right home! I could not be happier with the price we paid. She helped get us a credit after the inspection showed plumbing issues. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a home.”

John · Elkton, MD

Photo of Mary Ann York
Century 21 Gold Key Realty
“To whom it my concern, It is our immense pleasure to recommend Viola Salvato as a real estate agent for any individual or family searching for the ideal home. Viola had an initial meeting with us regarding our specific needs in a home as well as our budgetary limits. She is highly talented and immediately found us numerous listings of homes. She did not waste our time with homes that were not in line with our needs. Viola is a master with contract negotiation she came up with a deal that was good for us as well as making the seller happy. She knows the area like the back of her hand and there is nothing that escapes her attention when it comes to properties for sale in this area. We found Viola to be a highly attentive agent, almost as if we were her only customers, although we know that was not the case. She returned all phone calls and emails the same day. We never felt neglected or unimportant. She also is highly personable with an engaging personality. She is hands down the best!”

Scott Wilberg ·

Photo of Vi Salvato
Iowa Realty
“Brigita just simple "Excellent ". I have find my dream home through her. Excellent deal breaker , hardworking, excellent communication skills she have . We just loved her being our realtor. She make sure as a buyer we can buy our house smoothly. She made it happen . It was a great experience.”

Nusrat · Keansburg, NJ

Photo of Brigita Brown
Century 21 Action Plus Realty
“The agent demonstrated a considerable amount of experience and knowledge throughout the sale.”

Ibanga U. · Trenton, NJ

Photo of Paul & Kamila Hummel
Action USA Jay Robert Realtors
“Cathleen was helpful and responsive!”

Robert D H. · Flemington, NJ

Photo of Cathleen Henriquez-Ali
Coldwell Banker Realty
“Very professional and knowledgeable.... always available and excellent response time.”

Grace P. · Lakewood, NJ

Photo of Charles Howard
Century 21 Solid Gold Realty, LLC
“Victor is the best!! He did everything in his power to make the purchasing experience as smooth as possible. Always was available when called or texted.Has Knowledge,, honesty, value and professionalism.My highest recommendations to him!!”

Malakh · Long Branch, NJ

Photo of The Alhalabi Team
Century 21 C 21 Solid Gold
“Martin's support and guidance made possible the sale of my property in very challenging circumstances. His professional demeanor was critical to land the closing.”

Antonio T. · North Bergen, NJ

Photo of Martin Bianchi
Compass
“Christine was great. She knew what we were looking for and what we needed. She held our hand throughout this whole process. As first time home buyers I'm grateful we had her for the ride. She made everything easy, as well as easing my stress throughout it all. Her positive and wanting to help attitude is amazing. More Agents should be like her. Her patience and kindness is admireable. Here's to becoming part of the family! Cheers!”

Christina Orlando-Palombo · NJ

“Michael was very experienced and professional. He assisted me from the start in determining the best-selling price and provided council and insight throughout the process. He maintained excellent communication with me and all parties involved. Not only that, but he also followed up at the end to assure my satisfaction.”

Robert D. · Manchester Township, NJ

Photo of Michael Harbord
1st First Class Real Estate Agency
“Eric Valenzona was excellent! From the first phone call throughout the whole process, he was professional, pleasant, courteous, and overall extremely helpful.”

Mimi C. · Toms River, NJ

Photo of Eric Valenzona
Keller Williams Ocean Living

Frequently Asked Questions

There are more than 2 million real estate agents across the U.S., and you want to be sure the one you partner with is an experienced and trustworthy professional with strong local expertise covering the housing market in and around Mystic Island. Working with a proven agent will help you sell your home faster and for more money, and help you find your dream home at the best possible price.


Looking for an agent outside Mystic Island?

We’ll match you with top-rated real estate agents in just about any city—wherever your next move takes you.