Michael Teggart

Comey & Shepherd Realtors

Looking to sell your property, buy a new home, or just need some expert real estate advice?

Highlights *
28 recent sales
$88K - $575K
15 years experience
About
I have been working professionally in real estate in Greater Cincinnati since 2001. I am uniquely qualified with my experience in all aspects of the real estate transaction. I am an expert at getting things done, ensuring accuracy, and providing what my clients need in a timely and efficient manner for over twenty-three years. My extensive experience and knowledge will help you reach the closing table faster.

Ratings & Reviews
4.8 (62)

Steve H
Cincinnati, OH - Jun 24, 2025

Michael was fantastic throughout the entire process, keeping us informed through each step. He was a pleasure to work with.

Kristi Meyer
Nov 12, 2024

Michael made the process of selling our property remotely easy and effortless. We felt Michael communicated well and was always available when we needed or had questions. He has great knowledge of the market and more importantly, how to market our property which helped get it sold quickly. I would highly recommend Michael to anyone looking to buy or sell their property!

Lindsay Wile
Cincinnati, OH - Aug 7, 2024

Michael is an absolute pro and lovely human being. He is proactive, a great listener, extremly knowledgable, incredibly patient, and someone you can trust. Our first home purchase could not have gone smoother, thanks to Michael.

Michelle Dillingham
OH - Aug 29, 2023

Great agent!!

Ashley Simpson
Hyde Park, OH - Jul 26, 2022

I'm very happy we worked with Michael Teggart to purchase our home. Michael is a true professional. He was extremely responsive, communicative and committed to helping us find a home that met our family's needs. I felt supported during every step of the home buying process!

Raymond McNeel
Covedale, OH - Jun 7, 2022

Being new to Cincinnati, I needed an realtor who knew the various neighborhoods like the back of his hand in addition to being able to navigate through the current crazy market. This is exactly what I found in the team of Michael Teggart and Shawn Baker. They showed every property, warned me about pitfalls Zillow never tells you about, and oversaw a seemless transaction. Absolutely call them when you need someone you can trust.

Charlie Smith
Cincinnati, OH - May 26, 2022

I was highly skeptical of Realtors after a previous bad experience. However Michael was fantastic every step of the way. He was communicative, honest, and professional.He took our needs into consideration when selling our current home and purchasing a new one. Very easily accessible and always an advocate for his clients. I would use Micheal again in the future and recommend him to anyone buying a house in the Cincinnati area.

Jacob R. Mecklenborg
Cincinnati, OH - Dec 7, 2021

Michael and his recommended mortgage broker worked together to help get me a listing that generated a lot of interest. Thanks to them I somehow beat out several higher offers. Michael always responded quickly to any questions I had and there were no miscommunications throughout the process.

Anne Trapp
Cincinnati, OH - Dec 6, 2021

Michael stayed in contact on a regular basis. He worked to make sure things went smoothly despite setbacks with the process (on the other end). I trust him and am very appreciative of his knowledge about the business balanced with his people skills. It was a great experience.

The offer was made early after listing was posted but it took time to process the whole thing. Michael asked me/us what I/we wanted to do each step of the way. He was very accommodating in every way. I will recommend him to friends and family.

Matt
Cincinnati, OH - Oct 2, 2021

Buying a home was a big step for me. I never felt pressured by Michael. He protected my interests and was attentive. He always kept me up to speed and was responsive throughout the process. These are the reasons several of my family members have worked with him. We trust Michael Teggart.

The Bovats
OH - Sep 17, 2021

We really appreciated all Michael’s efforts helping us buy our first home, especially with the market conditions! Always open to talk, explain details, and overall just went above and beyond for us. We can’t thank him enough for helping us on this joir ey, and we couldn’t be happier!

Marie Carmack
Germantown, OH - Jul 1, 2021

Michael always goes the extra nine yards. Couldn’t be happier with him. He made himself available pretty much at all hours. Very knowledgeable. Offered great suggestions.

Mary Mosby
OH - Mar 1, 2021

Second time Michael Teggart was my realtor. I trust him to represent me. He quickly and accurately communicates all needed information. I would call him again.

Nasra and Robert
OH - Nov 24, 2020

Michael and Shawn went above and beyond at every opportunity. My wife and I felt confident that Michael and Shawn knew exactly what our needs were while looking for a new house. Once we found a home and began the closing process, they continued to be extremely helpful and informative. Hopefully we aren’t looking for a new house anytime soon, but we would definitely use Michael and Shawn again, and we will recommend their services to friends and family.

Masoud
Auburn, OH - Aug 10, 2020

Michael Teggart was professional, knowledgeable, and prompt. He was easy to communicate with. We were the buyers of a property and Michael clearly knew how to advocate for us. He was well versed in the community and the surrounding properties. We were very happy with his services.

Derek Bauman
Cincinnati, OH - Jan 25, 2019

Simply the best!

Woody Cornette
Walnut Hills, OH - Jan 25, 2019

I had worked with Michael several years ago when I was looking for a home at that time. After several offers and reconsideration I decided to postpone my home buying process. When I found this listing, I immediately reconnected with Michael because of his knowledge of the area, market, and purchasing process. I would highly recommend Michael.

Pat Feghali
OH - Jan 23, 2019

Michael was very friendly and professional and got the job done when others couldn’t. I would recommend him 100%!

Matt Woods
Cincinnati, OH - Jun 26, 2018

Michael and Shawn did a fantastic job of walking us through the process from start to finish. We got a full price offer within 24 hours and had an awesome experience. So much so that I referred them to my own parents for sale of their home.

Carla B.
Cincinnati, OH - Apr 3, 2018

Michael was very helpful and willing to assist in the sale if my home. Easy to talk to and very knowledgeable.

Cassandra Rinehart
Cincinnati, OH - Jan 4, 2018

I appreciate Michael's help and I have recommended him to my daughter to sell her house.

Christy
Cincinnati, OH - Jun 18, 2017

Michael helped me through a difficult purchase, and I am convinced that, without his help, I would not be currently living in the home that I wanted. He was terrific. I highly recommend him and his partner, Shawn Baker.

Katy Crosson
Cincinnati, OH - Nov 2, 2016

As a first-time homebuyer, Michael Teggart was a fantastic broker to choose for my recent condo purchase. I was unsure of the process including lending options, the home inspection process, and how to negotiate the contract with desired addenda items. Michael was calm, patient, and answered every question, making sure I understood what was normal for the process. His reassurances put me at ease and also helped manage my expectations of what were reasonable numbers to counter with in our bid. I believe I got a fair deal in the final price both parties decided, and I am certain it was because of Michael's coaching and strong experience in the Cincinnati market.

I absolutely loved working with Michael. He is funny, transparent, and also has a great business sense. During the entire process, I trusted Michael and was completely confident he was my advocate and working to ensure I walked away with the best deal possible. Michael pushed on my behalf to make sure the conversation between both parties progressed in an expedient manner. I would recommend Michael to any other homebuyer without reservation. This guy knows Over-the-Rhine and the urban core! There's no one else I'd rather work with. Hands down.

Derek Bauman
Over the Rhine, OH - Oct 27, 2016

Michael Teggart is my go to realtor. He's assisted me with the purchase/lease of multiple properties now and I highly recommend his services.

Chris and Lindsay
Avondale, OH - Oct 25, 2016

Michael work with my wife and I for over a year to help us find the perfect house. He was knowledgeable and helped us in the buying process. GREAT JOB help our family!

Professional Info

Brokerage

Comey & Shepherd Realtors
1440 Main St
Cincinnati, OH 45202

Licensed

Licensed REALTOR®
OH 2010001211

Awards

  • Comey & Shepherd Presidents Club
  • Comey & Shepherd Top Unit Sales
  • Comey & Shepherd Listing Leader
  • Circle of Excellence
  • Ohio Association of Realtors Presidents Club

Specialties

  • First-time buyers
  • Flipping & rehab
  • Foreclosures & Short sales
  • Investment & property management
  • Luxury properties
  • Military
  • Recreation & Vacation
  • Relocation

Hobbies

  • Animals
  • Cars & Automobiles
  • Community Activities
  • Family
  • Food & Cooking
  • Technology
  • Television & Film

Top Cities *

Cincinnati

  • 23 sales past 3 years
  • 37 days on market
  • $230K median price

Hillsboro

  • 1 sales past 3 years
  • days on market
  • $215K median price

Blanchester

  • 1 sales past 3 years
  • days on market
  • $220K median price

Service Areas (174 cities)

Addyston, OH Amberley, OH Amelia, OH Anderson Township, OH Arlington Heights, OH Batavia, OH Beckett Ridge, OH Bethel, OH Blanchester, OH Blue Ash, OH Blue Jay, OH Brecon, OH Bridgetown, OH Buford, OH Butlerville, OH Camp Dennison, OH Carlisle, OH Cherry Grove, OH Cheviot, OH Cincinnati, OH Clarksville, OH Cleves, OH Coldstream, OH Colerain, OH Collinsville, OH Concorde Hills, OH Covedale, OH Crosby Township, OH Cuba, OH Darrtown, OH Day Heights, OH Deerfield, OH Deer Park, OH Delhi, OH Delhi Hills, OH Delhi Township, OH Delshire, OH Dent, OH Dillonvale, OH Dry Ridge, OH Dry Run, OH Dunlap, OH Elizabethtown, OH Elmwood Place, OH Evendale, OH Fairfax, OH Fairfield, OH Fayetteville, OH Felicity, OH Finneytown, OH Five Points, OH Forest Park, OH Forestville, OH Four Bridges, OH Franklin, OH Fruit Hill, OH Glendale, OH Golf Manor, OH Goshen, OH Grandview, OH Greenhills, OH Groesbeck, OH Hamilton, OH Harrison, OH Highpoint, OH Hillsboro, OH Hooven, OH Hunter, OH Jacksonburg, OH Kenwood, OH Kings Mills, OH Lake Lorelei, OH Landen, OH Lebanon, OH Liberty Township, OH Lincoln Heights, OH Lockland, OH Loveland, OH Loveland Park, OH Mack, OH Mack North, OH Madeira, OH Madison Place, OH Maineville, OH Marathon, OH Mariemont, OH Mason, OH Miami, OH Miami Heights, OH Miamitown, OH Miami Township, OH Miamiville, OH Middletown, OH Midland, OH Milford, OH Millville, OH Monfort Heights, OH Monfort Heights East, OH Monfort Heights South, OH Monroe, OH Montgomery, OH Morgan, OH Morrow, OH Mount Carmel, OH Mount Healthy, OH Mount Healthy Heights, OH Mount Orab, OH Mount Repose, OH Mount St. Joseph, OH Mulberry, OH New Baltimore, OH New Burlington, OH New Miami, OH New Richmond, OH Newtonsville, OH Newtown, OH North Bend, OH Northbrook, OH North College Hill, OH Northgate, OH Norwood, OH Okeana, OH Olde West Chester, OH Oregonia, OH Owensville, OH Plainville, OH Pleasant Hills, OH Pleasant Plain, OH Pleasant Run, OH Pleasant Run Farm, OH Reading, OH Remington, OH Ridgewood, OH Roachester, OH Ross, OH Rossmoyne, OH Salem Heights, OH Seven Mile, OH Shandon, OH Sharonville, OH Shawnee, OH Sherwood, OH Silverton, OH Sixteen Mile Stand, OH Skyline Acres, OH South Lebanon, OH South Middletown, OH Springboro, OH Springdale, OH Springfield Township, OH St. Bernard, OH St. Martin, OH Summerside, OH Taylor Creek, OH Terrace Park, OH The Village of Indian Hill, OH Trenton, OH Turpin Hills, OH Washington, OH Washington Township, OH Waynesville, OH West Chester, OH West Elkton, OH Wetherington, OH White Oak, OH White Oak East, OH White Oak West, OH Whitewater Township, OH Williamsburg, OH Williamsdale, OH Withamsville, OH Woodlawn, OH Woodsdale, OH Wyoming, OH

* Sales data is calculated based on transaction information available to Agent Pronto at the time of publishing and may not accurately reflect all transactions for a given agent.