Home values in Toast have shifted notably compared with the broader Surry County area. The county’s typical home value is about $252,500 and has dipped 6.74% year over year, while Toast’s latest typical value sits a bit lower at $212,500. Even with that gap, Toast’s month-to-month movement has been sharp, with values jumping 165.63% heading into March 2026.
Current listing activity in Toast is limited, with just 5 homes on the market and only 1 new listing in the latest month. Homes that do hit the market are taking time to sell, spending a median of 68 days on the market, though that’s down 56.41% from the prior month, signaling that buyers are acting more quickly when they see the right fit.
Pricing patterns show a wide span between what’s typical and what’s being asked, with a median list price of $399,000 versus the $212,500 typical home value. Around 40% of listings have taken a price cut recently, yet the average sale-to-list ratio is holding at 1.0 and no recent sales closed above the list price. Looking ahead to April 2026, projections keep Toast’s median list price near $399,000, inventory around 5 homes, and the typical home value rising toward $278,750, making it important for both buyers and sellers to have an Agent Pronto expert connect them with a local agent who can navigate these conditions.
